Access the full text.
Sign up today, get DeepDyve free for 14 days.
Loading next page...
/lp/arxiv-cornell-university/in-situ-ion-induced-gelation-of-colloidal-dispersion-of-laponite-1PR1pRaL0U
- ISSN
- 0169-1317
- eISSN
- ARCH-3331
- DOI
- 10.1016/j.clay.2016.12.036
- Publisher site
- See Article on Publisher Site
Abstract
Aqueous dispersion of Laponite, when exposed to CO environment leads to in situ inducement of magnesium and lithium ions, which is, however absent when dispersion is exposed to air. Consequently, in the rheological experiments, Laponite dispersion preserved under CO shows more spectacular enhancement in the elastic and viscous moduli as a function of time compared to that exposed to air. By measuring concentration of all the ions present in a dispersion as well as change in pH, the evolving inter-particle interactions among the Laponite particles is estimated. DLVO analysis of a limiting case is performed, wherein two particles approach each other in a parallel fashion – a situation with maximum repulsive interactions. Interestingly it is observed that DLVO analysis explains the qualitative details of an evolution of elastic and viscous moduli remarkably well thereby successfully relating the macroscopic phenomena to the microscopic interactions. Keywords: Clay dispersion; Laponite dispersion; rheology; DLVO theory; inter- particle interactions. 1. Introduction The macroscopic properties of the colloidal dispersions are determined by various factors that include the nature, the shape and the size distribution of the particles, their concentration, the distribution of charges on the same, etc. [1]. These factors in turn determine the entropic considerations as well as the energetic interactions among the particles. With respect to the energetic interactions, while the change in pH determines the nature and the magnitude of the charges on a particle surface, gradual increase in the ionic concentration leads to progressive shielding of the surface changes [2]. In the present work a colloidal dispersion of Laponite, a disk shaped nanoparticle, in water is studied wherein many of the above mentioned factors are present. An aqueous dispersion of water shows spectacular enhancement in viscosity and elasticity as a function of time, and origin of this behavior has been a subject of intense investigation over past two decades [3-8]. However, unlike many naturally occurring clays, Laponite is vulnerable to chemical degradation when exposed to acidic environment [9-11], usually caused by dissolution of atmospheric carbon dioxide. Under such conditions, Laponite releases various kinds of ions in the aqueous media in which it is suspended [11]. In addition, pH of the dispersion also shows time dependent evolution. Both these in situ effects gradually alter the electrostatic interactions among the Laponite particles. Laponite is 2:1 is a synthetic clay mineral belonging to a family of hectorite +0.7 –0.7 clays with a chemical formula of the unit cell: Na [(Si Mg Li )O (OH) ] [12]. In 8 5.5 0.3 20 4 Laponite two sheets of tetrahedral silica sandwich octahedral sheet of magnesia leading to a single crystal of Laponite having disk like shape with 25±2.5 nm diameter and 0.92 nm thickness [13]. In the middle sheet, lithium isomorphically substitutes magnesium leading to deficiency of positive charge rendering outer two faces of Laponite a negative charge, which is compensated by sodium ions. The edge of a Laponite disk is composed of broken crystal and is dominated by Mg–OH, whose point of zero charge is around 12.5 [14]. Consequently, below this pH, the edge acquires a positive charge. As a result, in an aqueous medium with pH around 10, Laponite particles share edge – to – face attraction while face – to – face repulsion. Both these interactions contribute to structural build up in Laponite dispersion, which causes viscosity and elasticity of the same to show spectacular increase when Laponite is dispersed in water [15]. Incorporation of salt in aqueous dispersion of Laponite is observed to enhance the rate at which viscosity and elasticity of the same increases [16]. Such accelerated increase has been attributed to shielding that the dissociated ions provide to the charged faces of a disk, thereby reducing repulsion among the particles. This causes reduction in the repulsive barrier height for the particles to approach each other leading to faster structural build-up [16, 17]. While Laponite has been in use in variety of industrial applications and in academic studies, Laponite is susceptible to chemical degradation when exposed to acidic environment. Many groups have investigated the chemical stability of hectorite clay mineral over the past few decades [18-20], wherein H ions have been 2+ + suggested to react with clay causing Mg ions to leach. Typically, H ions have been proposed to attack the clay particles at two locations: the faces and the edges [18, 20]. It has been conjectured that H ions get adsorbed on the negatively charged faces, which eventually penetrate the tetrahedral silica sheet to react with octahedral magnesia sheet [19]. The attack on the edges, instead, is more direct. Since the former case involves two steps – the adsorption followed by the penetration – before the reaction takes place [19], it is believed to be slower than the latter [18, 20]. In the presence of weak acids, on the other hand, it has been claimed that H ions primarily attack the edges [18]. Interestingly Kreit et al. [19] reported that presence of salt stabilizes the clay, which they attribute to shielding of the clay particles by cations against H ions attack. The chemical stability of Laponite was investigated for the first time by Thompson and Butterworth [9] who claimed that degradation occurs when pH of a dispersion decreases below 9. They proposed that Laponite reacts with acid to undergo the following reaction [9]: + + 2+ + Na Si Mg Li O (OH) +12H +8H O0.7Na +8Si(OH) +5.5Mg +0.3Li (1) 0.7 8 5.5 0.3 20 4 2 4 Mourchid and Levitz [10] studied relaxation dynamics of dispersions preserved under air and N atmosphere. Interestingly they observed that samples preserved under air underwent gelation while that of kept under N atmosphere did not. Mourchid and Levitz [10] attribute this observation to dissolution of CO present in air, which 2+ + causes leaching of Mg and Li ions enhancing the ionic strength of the dispersions. 2+ + They proposed that increase in concentration of Mg and Li ions is responsible for accelerated aging of Laponite dispersion. Jatav and Joshi [11] carried out a systematic study wherein they exposed the Laponite dispersions with varying concentrations of Laponite and salt to air atmosphere. They observed that dispersions with high concentration of Laponite and/or that of salt do not show 2+ traces of leached Mg ions suggesting that the cations associated with a salt as well as the counter-ions provide a stabilizing effect against H ions attack. Very recently Mohanty and Joshi [21] proposed a chemical stability phase diagram which separates the chemically stable region from that of the unstable region as a function of time with respect to concentration of Laponite and that of salt. The faces of the disk/plate shaped particles of clays experience repulsive interactions due to their negatively charged nature, while experience attraction due to van der Waals interactions. As a result, historically this system has been studied as a model candidate for an application of DLVO theory [22], which accounts for electrostatic as well as van der Waals interactions among the particles [1]. While applying the theory the two negatively charged flat plates are considered to approach each other in a parallel fashion. This parallel configuration, which, while is only one of the possible configurations, provides information about the maximum repulsive interactions, therefore rendering a qualitative insight. In case of Laponite DLVO theory has been employed to infer about how the microstructure of Laponite dispersion gets affected by concentration of Laponite [16, 23], that of externally added salt [16, 23], concentration of counterions [24], temperature [16, 23] externally added polymers leading to steric interactions [25], etc. It has been observed that DLVO theory predicts the qualitative dynamics originating from the interparticle interactions very well. 2+ This work studies effect of Mg ion leaching by systematically exposing Laponite suspension to the CO2 environment. Furthermore, spontaneous evolution of 2+ Laponite dispersion with and without in situ Mg ion leaching is analyzed using rheology and DLVO theory, wherein the latter case involves consideration of multivalent cations. This work, on the one hand studies how the macroscopic rheological behavior changes as a function of time, while on the other hand, how the microscopic inter-particle interactions get altered with time is carefully analyzed. The objective of this work is to relate time evolving microscopic inter-particle interactions to the macroscopic rheological behavior of an aqueous dispersion of Laponite due to in situ change in the ionic concentration. 2. Material, sample preparation and experimental procedure In order to prepare aqueous dispersion, Laponite XLG (BYK Additives Inc.) was dried for 4 hours at 120°C. Before mixing Laponite with ultrapure water (resistivity 18.2 MΩ·cm) its pH was maintained at 10 by adding NaOH and molarity was fixed at predetermined value by adding NaCl. The mixing of Laponite and water was carried out for 45 min using Ultra Turrex drive, which leads to clear and colorless dispersion. In this work 2.8 mass% Laponite dispersion was studied with no externally added salt (0.1 mM Na ion concentration). The freshly prepared dispersions were stored in several polypropylene tubes of (2.74 cm diameter) 50 ml volume so as to have 5 ml of empty space above the dispersion. The samples were purged with N , air and CO . 2.8 mass% Laponite dispersion with 5 mM NaCl was 2 2 also used, and exposed this dispersion to only CO environment. The reason for employing this system is discussed in the next section. All the tubes were stored in different desiccators. The free space of the desiccators was also purged with a gas same as that in the free space of tubes. For each experiment a fresh tube was used without disturbing the others. The samples were investigated for a period of 30 days with an interval time of 5 days. This time, over which the sample was kept under quiescent condition, has been represented as rest time . Changes in pH and ionic conductivity of a dispersion were measured using Horiba F-71 pH Meter and Horiba DS-71 Conductivity meter respectively. Extent of 2+ dissolution of the Laponite particle leading to leaching of Mg ions was studied by performing complexometric titration, wherein dispersion is titrated against EDTA (ethylenediamine tetra-acetic acid) using EBT (eriochrome black-T) as the indicator. 2+ In the presence of Mg ions the dispersion turns red or purple on addition of EBT. To maintain the pH of 10 throughout the titration process, ammonia buffer solution (ammonium chloride/ ammonia) was used. As Laponite forms thixotropic gel, the viscosity/elasticity of the dispersion was first reduced by shearing it vigorously to ease the titration process. The titration’s end point occurs when EDTA changes the color of the dispersion to blue, which yields concentration of leached magnesium ion –3 . The method is sensitive enough to detect C = 10 mM [26]. Mg Mg The rheological study was carried out using a cup and bob geometry (bob diameter 10.004 mm with 0.407 mm gap) of Anton Paar MCR 501 rheometer. To erase history associated with the samples on a given day after preparation of the same (rest time), pre-shearing was performed by applying large amplitude oscillatory shear of 80000% for 10 minutes. Subsequent to shear-melting, dispersion was allowed G G to age wherein evolution of elastic modulus and viscous modulus were monitored by applying small amplitude oscillatory shear of 0.1% for 3 hours. The time elapsed since shear melting has been termed as waiting time or aging time ( ). Frequency of oscillation was maintained at 0.1 Hz. Unless otherwise mentioned, measurements of the ionic conductivity, pH, and C reported below are the values averaged over the entire volume of the tube. The Mg rheological study, on the other hand, requires very small amount of sample (around 3 ml), which was collected near the free surface. For 2.8 mass% dispersion studied here, no difference was found in the results when dispersion was stored under the N or air atmosphere for all the experiments. Therefore, only the results associated with the air atmosphere are reported below. All the experiments were performed at 25°C. 3. Results and discussion A visual observation of the 2.8 mass% dispersions without any salt preserved under CO and air indicates that dispersion stored under CO environment undergoes 2 2 liquid to soft solid transition after a rest time of 5 days. The samples stored under air atmosphere, on the other hand, took over 15 days to show soft solid-like consistency. More quantitatively the structural evolution of Laponite dispersion has been explored using rheology. In Fig. 1, G and G are plotted as a function of time t t elapsed since shear melting ( ) for experiments carried out on different for 2.8 w r mass% dispersion with no salt (air as well as CO environment) and 5 mM salt (CO 2 2 environment). All the dispersion samples studied in this work were in liquid state immediately after preparation of suspension on = 0 day, and the corresponding t values of G and G were very small compared to the values on 5 day. We G G have therefore not plotted the and data for = 0 day in Fig 1. For system with no salt preserved under air, Fig. 1(a) indicates that for all the explored , that t t both G and G increase with . In the limit of small , G dominates over G , w w but increase in G is faster than that of G . In due course G crosses over G ; and t at high , G starts decreasing after showing a maximum. However, the decrease in G is not apparent for =5 and 10 day as aging in these two systems is slow. Literature suggests that if waited for long enough waiting time, G of both these systems should also show decrease [16]. This behavior originates from inability of shear melting to completely obliterate evolved structure of aged aqueous dispersion of Laponite due to phenomenon known as irreversible aging [27, 28]. Consequently, at progressively higher , unbroken structure remained in a sample after the shear melting causes aging to begin at a mature state shifting the evolution of G and G to lower values of . FIG. 1. Elastic modulus (Gʹ, by closed symbols) and viscous modulus (Gʺ, open symbols) are plotted as a function of time elapsed since shear melting ( ) for 2.8 mass% dispersion with (a) no salt under air atmosphere, (b) no salt under CO environment, (c) 5 mM salt under CO environment for different rest times (bottom to top): 5 day (circles), 10 day (up triangles), 15 day (pentagons), 20 day (diamonds), 30 day (stars). No Salt (CO ) 5mM Salt (CO ) t [day] No Salt (Air/N ) -1 5 101520 25 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 t [day] t t FIG. 2. Storage modulus (G ) at = 3 h, is plotted as a function of for different w r Laponite dispersion samples: no salt stored in air (circles), no salt stored in CO t (squares), 5mM salt stored in CO (triangles). In the inset G is plotted against for 2 r the dispersions kept under CO for a better clarity. The lines serve as a guide to the eye. In Fig. 1(b) evolution of G and G is plotted for the samples preserved under CO environment. However, on =5 day itself, in a behavior very different 2 r from that shown in Fig. 1(a), system is observed to be in a state with G over an t order of magnitude greater than G . With increase in , G and G shift to the lower values of (when compared at same values of moduli) showing presence of irreversible aging. In Fig. 1(c) behavior of 2.8 mass% dispersion with 5 mM salt preserved under CO environment is plotted, which is qualitatively similar to that t t shown in Fig. 1(b). In Fig. 2 G at =3 h as a function of is plotted for all the w r t three systems reported in Fig. 1. On =0 day, G of no salt system preserved under G' [Pa] G [kPa] air and that of CO are identical as expected. On the other hand, the values of G t t for the salt containing system is higher than both the no salt systems on =0 and r w =3 h. However, over =0 to 5 days G of the no salt system preserved under CO r 2 increases very spectacularly. It is apparent from Figure 2 that G of two systems preserved under CO are comparable from day 5 to up to 20 days. But, after 20 days, G associated with the no salt system takes the higher values than G of 5 mM system as shown in the inset of Fig. 2 (The comparable values of G for 2.8 mass% 5 mM system preserved under CO with that of 2.8 mass% and no salt system preserved under CO over the initial period was the reason for employing the former system in this study). FIG. 3. Average concentration of leached magnesium ions ( ) in dispersion is Mg plotted as a function of for Laponite dispersion samples: with no salt stored under air (circles), with no salt stored under CO environment (squares), with 5mM salt stored in CO environment (triangles). This observation of Fig. 1 and 2 indicates that Laponite dispersion gets affected in CO environment causing accelerated structural evolution. Since 2+ dissolution of CO in Laponite dispersion is known to cause leaching of Mg ions from Laponite dispersion, complexometric titration is carried out on the dispersions at various locations away from the free surface. averaged over the length of tube Mg is plotted as a function of for the studied Laponite dispersion in Fig. 3. The 2+ samples preserved under air atmosphere do not show any detectible presence of Mg ions. The samples preserved under CO atmosphere, conversely, do show significant 2+ C t presence of Mg ions. While increases with increase in in presence of CO , Mg r 2 dispersion having salt shows lesser enhancement in compared to that having no Mg salt. This observation corroborates with the findings of Joshi and coworkers [11, 21], who claimed that increase in suppresses the creation of acidic environment locally, thereby stabilizing Laponite particles as observed in Fig. 3. 30 days 25 days 20 days 15 days 10 days 5 days 34 56 7 l [cm] FIG. 4. Concentration of leached magnesium ions ( ) for a dispersion without Mg salt stored under CO environment is plotted as a function of distance from the free surface (l ) for different (bottom to top): 5 days (squares), 10 days (circles), 15 days (up triangle), 20 days (stars), 25 days (diamonds), 30 days (pentagons). C t In Fig. 4, as a function of distance from the free surface at different is Mg r plotted for the dispersion stored under CO . At small rest times, only the sample closer to the free surface shows dissolution of magnesium. While curve gets shifted to C t higher values of with increase in rest time, for the lower (5, 10, and 15 days) Mg r the plot indicates decreasing trend of with the depth of the container. For Mg t C higher (20, 25, and 30 days), on the other hand, is observed to vary very r Mg weakly near the free surface. The observed behavior is expected as CO was purged 2+ at the top of the container. The process that leads to leaching of Mg ions involves three steps, dissolution of CO in aqueous media to form acidic environment, its 2+ diffusion to progressive lower depths, and its reaction with Laponite to produce Mg ions. In the initial days and deeper depths, the process is diffusion controlled. However, on later days once sufficient dissolution and diffusion has taken place the process is reaction controlled leading to the observed behavior. C [mM] Mg Fig. 5. pH is plotted as a function of for no salt dispersion stored in air (circles), no salt dispersion preserved under CO (squares), 5mM salt dispersion preserved under CO (triangles). The results of enhancement in modulus plotted in Fig. 1 and 2 and that of 2+ plotted in Fig. 3 and 4 indicate that greater concentration of Mg ions increases Mg the ionic strength of samples preserved under CO environment, which leads to 2+ accelerated structural evolution. However, prior to causing leaching of Mg ions, dissolution of CO in aqueous media also leads to decrease in pH of a dispersion, which has multiple effects on the dynamics of structural evolution. On one hand, + – change in pH affects relative concentration of H ions and OH ions, on the other hand decrease in pH causes edge of a Laponite particle to become more electropositive enhancing attraction between the edges and the faces. In Fig. 5 pH averaged over the length of a tube is plotted as a function of . Immediately after addition of Laponite in water, pH of the same is observed to be 10, the same value that of associated with initial pH of water. However, with increase in , pH of sample preserved under air reaches 10.3 within 5 days and remains constant thereafter. The samples kept under CO environment, conversely, show decrease in pH as a function of time due to formation of carbonic acid according to [29]: + – CO +H O ↔ H CO ↔ H +HCO (2) 2 2 2 3 3 The rate of decrease in pH for initial rest time is significant, but it becomes almost constant after a period of 15 days. The decrease in pH is however smaller for a sample containing salt than that for no salt system suggesting presence of salt indeed prohibits formation of acid in a sample. 2+ Leaching of Mg ions causes erosion of the Laponite particles. Typically, a single particle of Laponite contains 1000 unit cells. Since each unit cell has around 5.5 Mg atoms, a particle as a whole has 5500 Mg atoms. With knowledge of leached 2+ Mg ions, as shown in Fig. 3, the extent of erosion of the Laponite particles can be easily calculated. It is suggested by calculations that the largest concentration of 2+ leached Mg ions per particle for no salt system preserved under CO environment on day 30, constitute only 2.16% of the total magnesium ions per particle. As suggested by Kerr et al. [18] it is assumed that for a weakly acidic system, as is the present case (with pH always above 7), edge is more vulnerable for H ion attack. Consequently, considering Mg atoms to be evenly placed over the area of a Laponite disk, the calculation suggests erosion of only 2.2% of the area and around 1.1% decrease in the radius of a particle. The ionic conductivity of sample as a function of rest time is also measured, which is plotted in Fig. 6. For a freshly prepared dispersion without addition of salt, ionic conductivity is observed to be 0.75 mS/cm. For the samples preserved under air, the only contribution to conductivity over and above that associated with =0 day is dissociation of Na counter ions from faces and change in pH due to protonation of Mg-OH sites on the edges. However, both these contributions induce only marginal increase in conductivity as a function of time as shown in Fig. 6. Ionic conductivity of the dispersions stored under CO environment, on the other hand, shows significant increase with rest time. Furthermore, as expected, system having 5 mM salt has higher conductivity at small rest times. However, interestingly, system with no salt preserved under CO demonstrates greater increases in conductivity and exceeds that of associated with the former between 10 and 15 days of rest time. 2+ Given that increase in conductivity in both these systems is due to leaching of Mg ions and change in pH, considering the behavior shown in Fig. 3 and 5 respectively, the trend observed in Fig. 6 is not surprising. FIG. 6. Ionic conductivity is plotted as a function of for no salt dispersion stored in air (circles), no salt dispersion preserved under CO (squares), 5mM salt dispersion preserved under CO (triangles). The ionic conductivity of dispersion depends on concentration and mobilities of ions present in a dispersion given by [30]: en (3) ii Where is the ionic conductivity of dispersion, is the electron charge, while e and are respectively the ionic mobility and the concentration (ions/m ) of an i th type of ion. In Laponite dispersion studied in the present work, the various types of + – + 2+ + – + – ions present are: H , OH , Na , Mg , Li and Cl . The concentrations of H and OH pH n 10 ions are calculated respectively from the measured values of pH as: and pH14 2+ n 10 n . The concentration of Mg ions ( ) is obtained from complexometric Mg OH titration and is mentioned in Fig. 3. The stoichiometry given in equation (1) suggests 2+ + that for every 5.5 moles of Mg leaching, 0.3 moles of Li ions are also released. n n Consequently, estimation of leads to estimation of as well. The concentration Mg Li of Cl ions is same as amount of NaCl (5mM) added in the dispersion. Mobility of 7 3.623 10 the above mentioned ions is given by Haynes [31]: m /sV, 7 8 8 7 2 2 2 2.05 10 5.19 10 1.098 10 410 m /sV, m /sV, m /sV, OH Na Mg Li 8 2 2 + 7.908 10 m /sV and m /sV. The only unknown is concentration of Na ions Cl , which can be obtained through equation (3) from the measurement of ionic Na conductivity and with knowledge of the concentration of all the other ionic species. In principle the values of mentioned above are the bulk values, and may decrease because of the presence of charged Laponite particles in the media. However, since obtaining the actual values of is practically impossible, the bulk values for an estimation of is considered, which gives a lower bound on the same. Na FIG. 7. Debye screening length is plotted as a function of for no salt dispersion stored in air (circles), no salt dispersion preserved under CO (squares), 5mM salt dispersion preserved under CO (triangles). With knowledge of the concentration of the each ion present in the dispersion, 1 Debye screening length ( ) of the electric double layer (EDL) associated with the faces of Laponite particles can be calculated by [1]: kT 1 , (4) e n ii k where, is the valence of the ith ion, is Boltzmann constant, T is absolute i B temperature and is static permittivity of water. The variation of Debye screening 1 length is plotted in Fig. 7. For the dispersion without any salt stored under air, almost remains constant. For the other two systems (preserved under CO 1 environment), on the other hand, shows a remarkable decrease with . This 2+ decrease can be attributed to greater concentration of leached Mg ions and decrease in pH. For a system with 5 mM NaCl stored under CO atmosphere, owing to the + – presence of higher amount of Na and Cl ions in the dispersion, the initial value of 1 was found to be less than that for dispersion prepared without any salt (irrespective of the storage condition). However, with increase in rest time, decrease 1 in is observed to be less intense compared to that for a system with no salt 2+ preserved under CO atmosphere due to greater leaching of Mg ions in the latter. It is important to note that Debye screening length is not the only factor associated with the faces of Laponite particles, which determines their interactions with the neighboring particles. The dissociation of Na ions from the faces of the particles, in addition to the nature and concentration of ions present in the EDL, influence the electrostatic surface potential of the same. The combined effect of the surface potential and the Debye screening length is given by the DLVO theory (Derjaguin-Landau-Verwey-Overbeek) theory [1]. In order to solve the DLVO theory, two plates to approach each other in a parallel fashion is considered and free energy of interaction between them is evaluated as a function of half distance d between the same. The DLVO theory expresses the total free energy per unit area as a sum of that due to the van der Waals interaction and the double-layer repulsion vdW . DL WW W (5) vdW DL The free energy per unit area due to van der Waals interaction is given by [22]: A 11 8 Wd() , (6) vdW 22 2 48 (dd ) ( ) (2d) where is the Hamaker constant and is the thickness of unit sheets measured –20 between the same planes (for Laponite =1.06×10 J and =6.6 Å). The free energy per unit area between the two plates due to electrical double- layer repulsion is straightforward to obtain when dielectric media contains ionic species of only single valency. However, the present system contains different kinds of ionic species with monovalent and divalent valencies for which nonlinear Poisson- Boltzmann equation does not yield the analytical solution. For such case Israelachvili [1] suggested that free energy per unit area due to electrical double-layer repulsion can be approximated by an expression for a system containing monovalent ions (Na ions) that employs the correct Debye screening length obtained by considering effect of all the ions [given by equation (4)]. The approximated expression for is DL therefore given by [1]: 64n kT Na B 22 dd 2 , (7) We W e DLDL , max where, is the total concentration of Na ions in a dispersion obtained by solving Na γ = tanh(Φ 2) equation (3), and . The dimensionless surface electric potential, is 0 0 related to surface charge density by: 8s kTn inh (8) 00 rB Na The approximated forms of both the equations (7) and (8) are further justified by n n the fact that is around an order of magnitude greater than as shown in Fig. Na Mg FIG. 8. Average concentration of Na ions ( ) in suspension is plotted as a Na function of for Laponite suspension samples: with no salt stored under air (circles), with no salt stored under CO environment (squares), with 5mM salt stored in CO 2 2 environment (triangles). The charge on the Laponite surface is solely due to dissociation of Na ions from the same. Consequently, knowing concentration of dissociation of Na ions per face of Laponite particle, can be obtained as: nn Na Na e , (9) 2Am Lp where is the concentration of Na ions originating from the sources other than Na Laponite (NaCl and NaOH), is the area of a face of Laponite, factor 2 represents two faces per particle and are the number of Laponite particles per unit volume. In equation (9), the effect of adsorption of any cations on the negatively charged Wd () faces is neglected. W and are obtained by solving equations (7) to (9), DL, max DL Wd () while by solving equation (6) for , Wd() is obtained. vdW No Salt in CO 5mM Salt in CO No Salt in Air 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 t [day] W t FIG. 9. The leading term of equation (7), is plotted as a function of for no DL, max r salt dispersion stored under air (circles), no salt dispersion preserved under CO (squares), 5mM salt dispersion preserved under CO (triangles). In Fig. 9 , the leading order term of equation (7) is plotted, that DL, max describes the maximum height of the repulsive energy barrier due to only double layer interactions, as a function of for the three studied systems of Laponite dispersion. associated with a dispersion with no salt preserved under air DL, max remains practically constant over an entire duration. On the other hand, for a W t dispersion with no salt but preserved under CO , increases with . For a 2 DL, max r W t dispersion with 5 mM salt preserved under CO , increases with but the 2 DL, max r increase is not as significant as that of no salt system preserved under CO . 7.5 (a) Day 0 5.0 -2 2.5 d [nm] 0.0 0.0 2.5 5.0 7.5 d [nm] W [mJ/m ] W [mJ/m ] DL, max W [mJ/m ] 7.5 (b) Day 5 5.0 2d 2.5 0.0 0.0 2.5 5.0 7.5 d [nm] 7.5 (c) Day 15 5.0 2.5 0.0 0.0 2.5 5.0 7.5 d [nm] 7.5 (d) Day 30 5.0 2.5 0.0 0.0 2.5 5.0 7.5 d [nm] FIG. 10. Variation of total free energy of interaction plotted against the half-distance t t d between the Laponite plates (refer to the inset of b) for = 0 day (a), for =5 R r day (b), 15 day (c), and 30 day (d). For Fig. (a) the top curve represents dispersion with no salt stored in air as well as CO , while the bottom curve represents 2 2 W [mJ/m ] W [mJ/m ] W [mJ/m ] dispersion with 5mM salt preserved under CO . For remaining Fig., respectively from the smallest peak to the largest peak: dispersion with no salt stored in air, dispersion with 5mM salt preserved under CO , dispersion with no salt stored under CO . The 2 2 Inset in (a) indicates free energy contribution from van der Waals interactions, double layer repulsion, and their addition as a function of d for no salt dispersion on 0 day. W W The complete double layer repulsion term along with and W as a DL vdW function of d is plotted in the inset of Fig. 10(a). Both the double layer repulsion ( W () W ) as well as van der Waals attraction increases with decrease in d. The DL vdW sum of both the contributions first increases followed by a sharp decrease with decrease in d. While van der Waals attraction prevails over an interparticle distance below 1 nm, double layer repulsion can be seen to be affecting over 5 nm. In addition to van der Waals and double layer interactions, interactions due to ion – ion correlations also play an important role particularly below the interparticle distance of 1 nm [32, 33]. However, since there is no universally accepted free energy expression for the same, its effect has not been explicitly incorporated in equation (5) . Furthermore, usually the interactions due to ion-ion correlations are repulsive when monovalent ions are present, and attractive when divalent ions are present in between the plates [33]. Since the present system contains both the types of ions, the cumulative effect is expected to be combination of both attraction as well as repulsion. Interestingly, the van der Waals interactions also show effect over the same length-scale and the double layer repulsion persists between the faces over 5 nm (For the studied Laponite concentration of 2.8 mass %, the average interparticle distance is 35 nm). Therefore, in a parallel configuration the particles experience double layer repulsion over much longer length-scale before they experience the ion- ion correlation. As a result, it is expected that the qualitative effect of ion-ion correlations will not alter the interfacial interactions very significantly. Nonetheless 2+ with increase in Mg ion concentration, the attractive interactions between the plates in a parallel configuration will certainly augment. In Fig. 10(a) to (d) W as a function of d is plotted for the three studied t t systems for = 0, 5, 15, and 30 day respectively. On =0 day, the behavior of r r dispersion without salt preserved under air and CO atmosphere is identical. Furthermore, for =0 day the height as well as the width of the repulsive barrier between approaching surfaces for dispersion with 5 mM salt stored under CO is smaller compared to the no salt system as corroborated by figures 7 and 9. With increase in both the height as well as the width of repulsive barrier between approaching surfaces for dispersion without salt stored under air changes marginally compared to no salt dispersion stored under CO . The latter shows significant increase in barrier height while decrease in its width. The dispersion with 5 mM salt stored under CO also shows increase in barrier height and decrease in its width with increase in , but both the changes are not as intense as that of for no salt dispersion stored under CO . The behavior shown by Fig. 10 is applicable when two Laponite particles approach each other in a parallel fashion as shown in the inset of Fig. 10(b). However, in reality various Laponite particles can approach each other in any orientation and parallel fashion is just one of the possibilities. Consequently, for a no salt system preserved under air, while undergoing Brownian motion, when two particles approach each other in a non-parallel fashion, at progressively higher , attraction between more electronegative face and electropositive edge with decreased width of repulsive barrier accelerates formation of the structure via edge - to - face attractive bonds. The accelerated structure formation is responsible for shifting of G evolution to lower as shown in Fig. 1(a). However, since for no salt dispersion stored under air, change in all the three properties, namely the barrier height, its width, and pH is marginal, shift in G evolution is not spectacular. For a system 2+ with no salt preserved under CO environment, owing to leaching of Mg ions, both the height and the width of the energy barrier respectively becomes larger and narrower with increase in with significantly greater intensity compared to that of 2+ preserved under air. Moreover, due to greater concentration of Mg ions, attraction due to ion-ion correlations also prevails. On the other hand, increase in causes decrease in pH when preserved under CO environment which makes the edges of the particles more electropositive. It is therefore not surprising that all these three effects lead to more spectacular buildup of structure manifested in fast evolution of G in the no salt system preserved under CO environment compared to that of under air as shown in figure 1(b). Comparison of system with no salt and 5 mM salt preserved under CO environment is more involved. On one hand, it is known that presence of salt decreases the width of energy barrier. On the other hand, salt renders a stabilizing 2+ effect to a dispersion so that decrease in pH as well as amount of leached Mg ions is less than that of with no salt system preserved under CO as shown in Fig. 3 and 5. Figures 6 and 7 show that up to day 15, dispersion with 5 mM salt has greater ionic conductivity than that of with system with no salt, and therefore the faces of the particles in the former possess smaller Debye screening length. Furthermore, Fig. 9 suggests that is always larger for the dispersion exposed to CO DL, max 2 environment containing no salt than that of containing 5 mM salt. Smaller Debye screening length originating from greater ionic conductivity suggests reduction in activation barrier to form inter-particle bonds. Due to this effect aggregation rate in salt containing system should be faster than no salt containing system up to day 15. 2+ In addition, as concentration of Mg ions in the salt free system starts increasing compared to that of salt containing system, the overall attractive interactions among the particles in former due to ion-ion correlation also start influencing the dynamics. Furthermore, the lower pH represents more electropositive edges, while for higher W , which represents electronegativity of the faces, the rate of aggregation in salt DL, max containing system should be lower than no salt containing system throughout the explored rest times. Consequently, due to the competing effects, G of no salt system shows significant increase initially. After = 5 day the values of G for both the system remain comparable up to 20 days as shown in the inset of Fig. 2. However, beyond 20 days, observations of Fig. 5 to 9, indicate all the factors favor faster structure formation in dispersion exposed to CO environment containing no salt than that of containing 5 mM salt. Interestingly, as shown in the inset of Fig. 2, G of the no salt system indeed takes over G of dispersion containing 5 mM salt. This observation, therefore, demonstrates a close qualitative correspondence between microscopic electrochemical and macroscopic rheological behavior of aqueous Laponite dispersion in presence of in situ inducement of ions. In addition to academic aspect, the present work also has important implications from applications point of view. As mentioned before, Laponite is used as a rheology modifier or thickener in variety of industrial products such as home and personal care, mining, agrochemicals, pharmaceuticals, paints, paper, etc. It is highly likely that under usual application conditions, the aqueous products containing Laponite may get exposed acidic environment. Under such conditions, on one hand the chemical degradation induced by the same will lead to erosion of the Laponite particles. On the other hand, it releases various kinds of ions in the aqueous media in which Laponite is suspended altering electrostatic interactions among the particles. Both these effects are not desirable for an intended end use of the product containing Laponite particles. The present work demonstrates such possibility under controlled conditions. 4. Conclusion In this work the interrelation between macroscopic rheological behavior and microscopic electrochemical properties are studied for an aqueous dispersion of Laponite, which demonstrates in situ change in ionic concentration when preserved under CO atmosphere. In general, in the rheological experiments carried out on a latter day t after preparation, evolution of G subsequent to shear melting shows accelerated evolution. The acceleration is observed to be very spectacular for dispersion preserved under CO environment. The complexometric titration and 2+ conductivity measurements reveal significant in situ leaching of Mg ions and high level ionic conductivity in dispersions preserved under CO environment. On the other hand, in comparison, a dispersion preserved under air shows modest ionic 2+ conductivity and no traces of leached Mg ions. Furthermore, the pH of dispersion preserved under CO decreases substantially unlike the pH of preserved under air that shows only slight increase. Knowledge of ionic conductivity and concentration of various participating ions leads to the surface charge density and Debye screening length associated with the faces of Laponite particle in dispersions preserved under various conditions. Also the DLVO theory for two Laponite particles approaching each other in parallel fashion is studied. Very interestingly, analysis of the DLVO results, in addition to the effect of pH on the edge charge of Laponite, explain the rheological behavior of the dispersion very well relating macroscopic behavior to microscopic inter-particle interactions. Acknowledgment The financial support from the department of Atomic Energy- Science Research Council, Government of India (2012/21/02-BRNS/1097) is greatly acknowledged. References 1. Israelachvili, J.N., Intermolecular and Surface Forces. 3 ed. 2010, London: Academic Press. 2. Russel, W.B., D. A. Saville, and W.R. Schowalter., Colloidal Dispersions. 1989: Cambridge University Press. 3. Shahin, A. and Y.M. Joshi, Hyper-Aging Dynamics of Nanoclay Suspension. Langmuir, 2012. 28(13): p. 5826-5833. 4. Ruzicka, B. and E. Zaccarelli, A fresh look at the Laponite phase diagram. Soft Matter, 2011. 7(4): p. 1268-1286. 5. Angelini, R., E. Zaccarelli, F.A. de Melo Marques, M. Sztucki, A. Fluerasu, G. Ruocco, and B. Ruzicka, Glass–glass transition during aging of a colloidal clay. Nat Commun, 2014. 5: p. 4049. 6. Jonsson, B., C. Labbez, and B. Cabane, Interaction of Nanometric Clay Platelets. Langmuir, 2008. 24(20): p. 11406-11413. 7. Morariu, S. and M. Bercea, Effect of Temperature and Aging Time on the Rheological Behavior of Aqueous Poly(ethylene glycol)/Laponite RD Dispersions. Journal of Physical Chemistry B, 2012. 116(1): p. 48-54. 8. Atmuri, A.K. and S.R. Bhatia, Polymer-Mediated Clustering of Charged Anisotropic Colloids. Langmuir, 2013. 29(10): p. 3179-3187. 9. Thompson, D.W. and J.T. Butterworth, The nature of laponite and its aqueous dispersions. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 1992. 151(1): p. 236-243. 10. Mourchid, A. and P. Levitz, Long-term gelation of laponite aqueous dispersions. Physical Review E, 1998. 57(5): p. R4887-R4890. 11. Jatav, S. and Y.M. Joshi, Chemical stability of Laponite in aqueous media. Applied Clay Science, 2014. 97–98(0): p. 72-77. 12. Laponite: Structure, chemistry and relationship to natural clays. Laponite: Structure, chemistry and relationship to natural clays, Laponite Technical Bulletin, 1990. Vol. L104-90-A: p. 1-15. 13. Kroon, M., G.H. Wegdam, and R. Sprik, Dynamic light scattering studies on the sol-gel transition of a suspension of anisotropic colloidal particles. Phys. Rev. E, 1996. 54(6): p. 6541-6550. 14. Stumm, W., Chemistry of the solid-liquid interface. 1992, New York: John Wiley & Sons. 15. Joshi, Y.M., Model for cage formation in colloidal suspension of laponite. J. Chem. Phys., 2007. 127(8): p. 081102. 16. Shahin, A. and Y.M. Joshi, Physicochemical effects in aging aqueous laponite suspensions. Langmuir, 2012. 28(44): p. 15674-15686. 17. Mongondry, P., J.F. Tassin, and T. Nicolai, Revised state diagram of Laponite dispersions. J.Colloid Interface Sci., 2005. 283(2): p. 397-405. 18. Kerr, G.T., R.H. Zimmerman, H.A. Fox, and F.H. Wells, Degradation of hectorite by hydrogen ion. Clays Clay Miner., 1956. 4: p. 322. 19. Kreit, J.F., I. Shainberg, and A.J. Herbillon, Hydrolysis and decomposition of hectorite in dilute salt-solutions. Clays and Clay Minerals, 1982. 30(3): p. 223- 20. Tiller, K.G., Stability of hectorite in weakly acidic solutions I. A chemical study of the dissolution of hectorite with special reference to the release of silica. Clay Minerals, 1968. 7: p. 245-259. 21. Mohanty, R.P. and Y.M. Joshi, Chemical Stability Phase Diagram of Aqueous Laponite Dispersions. Applied Clay Science, 2016. 119: p. 243-248. 22. Van Olphen, H., An Introduction to Clay Colloid Chemistry. 1977, New York: Wiley. 23. Saha, D., R. Bandyopadhyay, and Y.M. Joshi, Dynamic Light Scattering Study and DLVO Analysis of Physicochemical Interactions in Colloidal Suspensions of Charged Disks. Langmuir, 2015. 31(10): p. 3012-3020. 24. Jatav, S. and Y.M. Joshi, Analyzing fractal gel of charged oblate nanoparticles in suspension using time resolved rheometry and DLVO theory. Faraday Discussions, 2016. 186: p. 199-213. 25. Sun, W., Y. Yang, T. Wang, H. Huang, X. Liu, and Z. Tong, Effect of adsorbed poly(ethylene glycol) on the gelation evolution of Laponite suspensions: Aging time-polymer concentration superposition. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 2012. 376(1): p. 76-82. 26. Vogel, A.I., A textbook of quantitative inorganic analysis. 1978, New York: Longman. 27. Shahin, A. and Y.M. Joshi, Irreversible Aging Dynamics and Generic Phase Behavior of Aqueous Suspensions of Laponite. Langmuir, 2010. 26(6): p. 4219– 28. Jatav, S. and Y.M. Joshi, Rheological signatures of gelation and effect of shear melting on aging colloidal suspension. Journal of Rheology, 2014. 58(5): p. 1535-1554. 29. Greenwood, N.N. and A. Earnshaw, Chemistry of the Elements. 1997, Oxford: Elsevier Butterworth-Heinemann. 30. Benenson, W., J.W. Harris, H. Stöcker, and H. Lutz, Handbook of Physics. 2002, New York: Springer-Verlag. 31. Haynes, W.M., CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics. 2010, BocaRaton: CRC Press. 32. Wennerström, H. and B. Jönsson, Amphiphile-water systems and electrostatic interactions. J. Phys. France, 1988. 49(6): p. 1033-1041. 33. Kjellander, R., Ion-ion correlations and effective charges in electrolyte and macroion systems. Berichte der Bunsengesellschaft für physikalische Chemie, 1996. 100(6): p. 894-904.
Journal
Condensed Matter – arXiv (Cornell University)
Published: Dec 19, 2018