Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Reflections on the human-algorithm complex duality perspectives in the auditing process

Reflections on the human-algorithm complex duality perspectives in the auditing process Algorithms, artificial intelligence (AI), machines, and all emerging digital technologies disrupt traditional auditing, raising many questions and debates. One of the central issues of this debate is the human-algorithms complex duality, which focuses on this investigation. This study aims to investigate the algorithms’ penetration in auditing activities, with a specific focus of a future scenario on the human-algorithms interaction in performing audits as intelligent teams.Design/methodology/approachThe research uses a qualitative reflexive thematic analysis, taking into consideration the academic literature, as well as professional reports and websites of the “Big Four” audit firms and internationally recognized accounting bodies.FindingsThe results debate the complex duality between algorithms and human-based actions in the institutional settings of auditing activities by highlighting the actual stage of algorithms, machines and AI emergence in audit and providing real-life examples of their use in the audit. Furthermore, they emphasize the strengths and weaknesses of algorithms compared to human beings. Based on the results, a discussion on the human-algorithms interaction from the lens of the Human-in-the-Loop (HITL) approach concludes that the Auditor-Governing-the-Loop may be a possible scenario for the future of the auditing profession.Research limitations/implicationsThis study is exploratory, investigating academia and practitioners’ written debates, analyzes and reports, limiting its applicability. Nonetheless, the paper adds to the ongoing discussion on emerging technologies and auditing research. Finally, the authors address some potential biases associated with the extended use of algorithms and discuss future research implications. Future research should empirically test how the human-algorithms tandem is working and how AI and other emerging technologies will affect auditing activities and the auditing profession.Practical implicationsThe study provides valuable insights for audit firms, auditors, professional organizations and standard-setters, and regulators revealing the implication of algorithms’ penetration in auditing activities from the human-algorithms complex duality perspective. Moreover, the academic education and research implications are highlighted, in terms of updating the educational curriculum by including the new technologies issues, as well as the need for further research investigations concerning the human-algorithms interactions issues as, for example, trust, legal restrictions, ethical concerns, security and responsibility.Originality/valueThe research uses HITL as a novel paradigm for responsible AI development in auditing. The study points to the strategic value of a HITL pattern for organizational reflexivity that, according to the study, ensures that the algorithm’s output meets the audit organization’s requirements and changes in the environment. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Qualitative Research in Accounting & Management Emerald Publishing

Reflections on the human-algorithm complex duality perspectives in the auditing process

Download PDF
31 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/reflections-on-the-human-algorithm-complex-duality-perspectives-in-the-h5jFoD1Yiz

References

References for this paper are not available at this time. We will be adding them shortly, thank you for your patience.

Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
1176-6093
eISSN
1176-6093
DOI
10.1108/qram-04-2021-0059
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Algorithms, artificial intelligence (AI), machines, and all emerging digital technologies disrupt traditional auditing, raising many questions and debates. One of the central issues of this debate is the human-algorithms complex duality, which focuses on this investigation. This study aims to investigate the algorithms’ penetration in auditing activities, with a specific focus of a future scenario on the human-algorithms interaction in performing audits as intelligent teams.Design/methodology/approachThe research uses a qualitative reflexive thematic analysis, taking into consideration the academic literature, as well as professional reports and websites of the “Big Four” audit firms and internationally recognized accounting bodies.FindingsThe results debate the complex duality between algorithms and human-based actions in the institutional settings of auditing activities by highlighting the actual stage of algorithms, machines and AI emergence in audit and providing real-life examples of their use in the audit. Furthermore, they emphasize the strengths and weaknesses of algorithms compared to human beings. Based on the results, a discussion on the human-algorithms interaction from the lens of the Human-in-the-Loop (HITL) approach concludes that the Auditor-Governing-the-Loop may be a possible scenario for the future of the auditing profession.Research limitations/implicationsThis study is exploratory, investigating academia and practitioners’ written debates, analyzes and reports, limiting its applicability. Nonetheless, the paper adds to the ongoing discussion on emerging technologies and auditing research. Finally, the authors address some potential biases associated with the extended use of algorithms and discuss future research implications. Future research should empirically test how the human-algorithms tandem is working and how AI and other emerging technologies will affect auditing activities and the auditing profession.Practical implicationsThe study provides valuable insights for audit firms, auditors, professional organizations and standard-setters, and regulators revealing the implication of algorithms’ penetration in auditing activities from the human-algorithms complex duality perspective. Moreover, the academic education and research implications are highlighted, in terms of updating the educational curriculum by including the new technologies issues, as well as the need for further research investigations concerning the human-algorithms interactions issues as, for example, trust, legal restrictions, ethical concerns, security and responsibility.Originality/valueThe research uses HITL as a novel paradigm for responsible AI development in auditing. The study points to the strategic value of a HITL pattern for organizational reflexivity that, according to the study, ensures that the algorithm’s output meets the audit organization’s requirements and changes in the environment.

Journal

Qualitative Research in Accounting & Management – Emerald Publishing

Published: Jun 6, 2022

Keywords: Algorithms; Auditing; Artificial intelligence; Human-in-the-loop; Auditor-in-the-loop; Emergent technologies; Big four; Human intelligence

References

  • Auditing in the smart machine age, moving beyond the hype to explore the evolution of the auditing profession in the smart machine age
    Alderman, J.
  • The coming disruption of drones, robots, and bots how will it affect CPAs and accounting practice?
    Appelbaum, D.; Nehmer, R.
  • Accounting, accountability, social media and big data: revolution or hype?
    Arnaboldi, M.; Busco, C.; Cuganesan, S.
  • Knowledge workers’ reactions to a planned introduction of robotic process automation - empirical evidence from an accounting firm
    Asatiani, A.; Penttinen, E.; Ruissalo, J.; Salovaara, A.; Hirschheim, R.; Heinzl, A.; Dibbern, J.
  • The robots are coming… but aren’t here yet: the use of artificial intelligence technologies in the public accounting profession
    Bakarich, K.M.; O’Brien, P.
  • Computers that learn to help
    Brunskill, E.
  • Alexa, write an audit opinion: adopting intelligent virtual assistants in accounting workplaces
    Burns, M.B.; Igou, A.
  • Why AI in audit works for reasonable assurance
    Colthart, J.
  • Man versus machine: complex estimates and auditor reliance on artificial intelligence
    Commerford, B.P.; Dennis, S.A.; Joe, J.R.; Ulla, J.
  • Accounting, professions and regulation: locating the sites of professionalization
    Cooper, D.J.; Robson, K.
  • Robotic process automation in public accounting
    Cooper, L.A.; Holderness, D.K.; Sorensen, T.L.; Wood, D.A.
  • Perceptions of robotic process automation in big 4 public accounting firms: do firm leaders and lower-level employees agree?
    Cooper, L.A.; Holderness, D.K.; Sorensen, T.L.; Wood, D.A.
  • Innovation in audit takes the analytics, AI route. Audit analytics, cognitive technologies to set accountants free from grunt work
  • 16 Artificial intelligence projects from deloitte practical cases of applied AI
  • Thriving in the era of pervasive AI. Deloitte’s state of AI in the enterprise. 3rd edition
  • 2020 Technology industry outlook. As cloud and AI deployments rise, edge computing is poised to join the mix
  • A study of robotic process automation use cases today for tomorrow’s business
    Devarajan, Y.
  • Machine learning in auditing: current and future applications
    Dickey, G.; Blanke, S.; Seaton, L.
  • How AI will enable us to work smarter, faster
  • Why AI is both a risk and a way to manage risk
  • How artificial intelligence will transform the audit
  • How audit digitization reflects a transformative age
  • EY virtual analytics infrastructure (EY virtual)
  • Why IA transformation initiatives should be people-centric
  • A framework for using robotic process automation for audit tasks
    Eulerich, M.; Pawlowski, J.; Waddoups, N.; Wood, D.A.
  • AI in the accounting big four – comparing Deloitte, PwC, KPMG, and EY
    Fagella, D.
  • I’m not biased, am I?
    Fay, R.; Montague, N.R.
  • Understanding the impact of technology on audit and finance
  • A review of ERP research: a future agenda for accounting information systems
    Grabski, S.V.; Leech, S.A.; Schmidt, P.J.
  • Exploring the impact of artificial intelligence on the accounting profession
    Greenman, C.
  • Augmenting the algorithm: emerging human-in-the-loop work configurations
    Grønsund, T.; Aanestad, M.
  • Applying robotic process automation (RPA) in auditing: a framework
    Huang, F.; Vasarhelyi, M.A.
  • Exploring artificial intelligence and the accountancy profession: opportunity, threat, both, neither?
  • Artificial intelligence’s impact on business
  • Why accountants must embrace machine learning
  • From algorithms to deep learning, what you need to know about AI
  • Research ideas for artificial intelligence in auditing: the formalization of audit and workforce supplementation
    Issa, H.; Sun, T.; Vasarhelyi, M.A.
  • Will algorithms blind people? The effect of explainable AI and decision-makers’ experience on AI-supported decision-making in government
    Janssen, M.; Hartog, M.; Matheus, R.; Yi Ding, A.; Kuk, G.
  • Impact of RPA technologies on accounting systems
    Kaya, C.T.; Turkyilmaz, M.; Birol, B.
  • Big four accounting firms delve into artificial intelligence
    Kepes, B.
  • Early evidence of digital labor in accounting: innovation with robotic process automation
    Kokina, J.; Blanchette, S.
  • The emergence of artificial intelligence: how automation is changing auditing
    Kokina, J.; Davenport, T.H.
  • The creative CIO’s agenda: getting started with digital labor
  • Rise of the humans 1: the integration of digital and human labor
  • Rise of the humans 2: practical advice for shaping a workforce of bots and their bosses
  • Audit 2025: the future is now
  • Rise of the humans 3: shaping the workforce of the future
  • Digital labor in the audit
  • Machine learning and the audit: rise of the machines?
  • Reinventing work: a sequel to the rise of the humans series
  • Digital accounting: opportunities, threats and the human factor
    Kruskopf, S.; Lobbas, C.; Meinander, H.; Söderling, K.; Martikainen, M.; Lehner, O.M.
  • Robotic process automation in audit and accounting
    Lacurezeanu, R.; Tiron-Tudor, A.; Bresfaleanu, P.
  • How does artificial intelligence shape the audit industry?
    Law, K.; Shen, M.
  • Development of an intelligent NLP-based audit plan knowledge discovery system
    Li, Q.; Liu, J.
  • Technology, jobs and the future of work
  • The future of work: how the new order of business will shape your organization, your management style, and your life
    Malone, T.W.; Sørensen, C.; Yoo, Y.; Lyytinen, K.; DeGross, J.I.
  • Robotic process automation for auditing
    Moffitt, K.; Rozario, A.M.; Vasarhelyi, M.A.
  • The role of internet-related technologies in shaping the work of accountants: new directions for accounting research
    Moll, J.; Yigitbasioglu, O.
  • The ethical implications of using artificial intelligence in auditing
    Munoko, I.; Brown-Liburd, H.L.; Vasarhelyi, M.
  • Intelligent process automation: an overview over the future of auditing
    Nunes, T.; Leite, J.; Pedrosa, I.
  • The application of artificial intelligence in auditing: looking back to the future
    Omoteso, K.
  • Technology and the audit of today and tomorrow
  • How AI will turn auditors into analysts
    Persico, F.; Sidhu, H.
  • Confidence in the future: human and machine collaboration in the audit
  • Confidence in the future: human and machine collaboration in the audit
  • A people-centric approach for a successful front-office transformation
  • Why auditing in the time of COVID-19 requires a delicate balance of human and machine
  • Labor market risks of industry 4.0, digitization, robots and AI
    Rajnai, Z.; Kocsis, I.
  • AI-enhanced audit inquiry: a research note
    Raschke, R.L.; Saiewitz, A.; Kachroo, P.; Lennard, J.B.
  • Accounting and auditing at the time of blockchain technology: a research agenda
    Schmitz, J.; Leoni, G.
  • The fourth industrial revolution
    Schwab, J.
  • Artificial intelligence and ethics: ethics and the dawn of decision-making machines
    Shaw, K.
  • Trust in technology: raising the bar in the audit industry
    Sidhu, H.
  • AI, robotics and the future of jobs’, pew research Centre
    Smith, A.; Anderson, J.
  • Money, honour and duty: global professional service firms in comparative perspective
    Spence, C.; Zhu, J.; Endo, T.; Matsubara, S.
  • Applying deep learning to audit procedures: an illustrative framework
    Sun, T.S.
  • The reports of my death are greatly exaggerated - artificial intelligence research in accounting
    Sutton, S.G.; Holt, M.; Arnold, V.
  • Managing change with and through blockchain in accountancy organizations: a systematic literature review
    Tiron-Tudor, A.; Deliu, D.; Farcane, N.; Dontu, A.
  • Big data’s disruptive effect on job profiles: management accountants’ case study
    Tiron-Tudor, A.; Deliu, D.
  • Automation is enabling digital transformation in governments around the world
  • Rationality and politics of algorithms. Will the promise of big data survive the dynamics of public decision making?
    van der Voort, H.G.; Klievink, A.J.; Arnaboldi, M.; Meijer, A.J.
  • How robotic process automation is transforming accounting and auditing
    Vasarhelyi, M.; Rozario, A.
  • Intelligent process automation in audit
    Zhang, C.A.
  • The impact of artificial intelligence and blockchain on the accounting profession
    Zhang, Y.; Xiong, F.; Xie, Y.; Fan, X.; Gu, H.
  • Deloitte teams with NVIDIA to launch the Deloitte center for AI computing
  • How to harness the power of trust and data