Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Too big to fail? Accounting for predictions of financial distress in English professional football clubs

Too big to fail? Accounting for predictions of financial distress in English professional... This paper analyses English Premier League (EPL) and English Football League (EFL) championship clubs during the period 2002–2019 to anticipate financial distress with specific reference to footballs' Financial Fair Play (FFP) regulations.Design/methodology/approachData was collected for 43 professional football clubs competing in the EPL and Championship for the financial year ends 2002–2019. Analysis was conducted using the Z-score methodology and additional statistical tests were conducted to measure differences between groups. Data was split into two distinct periods to analyse club finances pre- and post-FFP.FindingsThe results show significant cases of financial distress amongst clubs in both divisions and that Championship clubs are in significantly poorer financial health than EPL clubs. In some cases, financially sustainability has worsened post-FFP. The “big 6” clubs – due to their size – seem to be more financially sound than the rest of the EPL, thus preventing a “too big to fail” effect. Overall, the financial situation in English football remains poor, a position that could be exacerbated by the economic crisis, caused by COVID-19.Research limitations/implicationsThe findings are not generalisable outside of the English football industry and the data is susceptible to usual accounting techniques and treatments.Practical implicationsThe paper recommends a re-distribution of broadcasting rights, on a more equal basis and incentivised with cost-reduction targets. The implementation of a hard salary cap at league level is also recommended to control costs. Furthermore, FFP regulations should be re-visited to deliver the original objectives of bringing about financial sustainability in European football.Originality/valueThe paper extends the evidence base of measuring financial distress in professional team sports and is also the first paper of its kind to examine this in relation to Championship clubs. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Applied Accounting Research Emerald Publishing

Too big to fail? Accounting for predictions of financial distress in English professional football clubs

Download PDF
21 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/too-big-to-fail-accounting-for-predictions-of-financial-distress-in-DH2R84TKq5
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
0967-5426
DOI
10.1108/jaar-05-2020-0095
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

This paper analyses English Premier League (EPL) and English Football League (EFL) championship clubs during the period 2002–2019 to anticipate financial distress with specific reference to footballs' Financial Fair Play (FFP) regulations.Design/methodology/approachData was collected for 43 professional football clubs competing in the EPL and Championship for the financial year ends 2002–2019. Analysis was conducted using the Z-score methodology and additional statistical tests were conducted to measure differences between groups. Data was split into two distinct periods to analyse club finances pre- and post-FFP.FindingsThe results show significant cases of financial distress amongst clubs in both divisions and that Championship clubs are in significantly poorer financial health than EPL clubs. In some cases, financially sustainability has worsened post-FFP. The “big 6” clubs – due to their size – seem to be more financially sound than the rest of the EPL, thus preventing a “too big to fail” effect. Overall, the financial situation in English football remains poor, a position that could be exacerbated by the economic crisis, caused by COVID-19.Research limitations/implicationsThe findings are not generalisable outside of the English football industry and the data is susceptible to usual accounting techniques and treatments.Practical implicationsThe paper recommends a re-distribution of broadcasting rights, on a more equal basis and incentivised with cost-reduction targets. The implementation of a hard salary cap at league level is also recommended to control costs. Furthermore, FFP regulations should be re-visited to deliver the original objectives of bringing about financial sustainability in European football.Originality/valueThe paper extends the evidence base of measuring financial distress in professional team sports and is also the first paper of its kind to examine this in relation to Championship clubs.

Journal

Journal of Applied Accounting Research – Emerald Publishing

Published: Jan 25, 2021

Keywords: Financial crisis; Z-score; English professional football; English premier league; Financial fair play

References

  • A methodology for predicting company failure in the construction industry
    Abidali, A.F.; Harris, F.
  • Satellite television and football attendance: the not so super effect
    Allan, S.
  • ZETATM analysis A new model to identify bankruptcy risk of corporations
    Altman, E.I.; Haldeman, R.G.; Narayanan, P.
  • Evaluation of a company as a going concern
    Altman, E.I.; McGough, T.P.
  • Financial ratios, discriminant analysis and the prediction of corporate bankruptcy
    Altman, E.I.
  • Business bankruptcy prediction models: a significant study of the Altman's Z score model
    Anjum, S.
  • Regulatory intensity in English and German professional football
    Bachmaier, B.; Lammert, J.; Plumley, D.; Wilson, R.; Hovemann, G.
  • Satellite broadcasting and match attendance: the case of rugby league
    Baimbridge, M.; Cameron, S.; Dawson, P.
  • Satellite television and the demand for football: a whole new ball game?
    Baimbridge, M.; Cameron, S.; Dawson, P.
  • Spanish football in need of financial therapy: cut expenses and inject capital
    Barajas, A.; Rodríguez, P.
  • Financial ratios as predictors of failure
    Beaver, W.H.
  • Topological network properties of the European football loan system
    Bond, A.J.; Widdop, P.; Parnell, D.
  • Financial statement analysis and insolvency forecast models: a proposal for local firms
    Cantoni, E.
  • Performance measurement systems and the enactment of different institutional logics: insights from a football organization
    Carlsson-Wall, M.; Kraus, K.; Messner, M.
  • An integrated framework for the financial analysis of sustainability
    Castro, N.R.; Chousa, J.P.
  • Predicting corporate failure: empirical evidence for the UK
    Charitou, A.; Neophytou, E.; Charalambous, C.
  • A discriminant analysis of predictors of business failure
    Deakin, E.B.
  • Are banks too big to fail or too big to save? International evidence from equity prices and CDS spreads
    Demirgüç-Kunt, A.; Huizinga, H.
  • Overinvestment in team sports leagues: a contest theory model
    Dietl, H.M.; Franck, E.; Lang, M.
  • The financial performance of the Greek football clubs
    Dimitropoulos, P.
  • Why does financial regulation matter for European professional football clubs?
    Drut, B.; Raballand, G.
  • EFL statement: board update on coronavirus
  • State aid: commission adopts revised guidelines for supporting firms in difficulty
  • Performance evaluation for airlines including the consideration of financial ratios
    Feng, C.M.; Wang, R.T.
  • Championship clubs ready to revolt over new TV deal with Sky
    Fisher, B.; James, S.
  • New issues in attendance demand: the case of the English football league
    Forrest, D.; Simmons, R.
  • Broadcasting, attendance and the inefficiency of cartels
    Forrest, D.; Simmons, R.; Szymanski, S.
  • Outcome uncertainty and the couch potato audience
    Forrest, D.; Simmons, R.; Buraimo, B.
  • A theoretical analysis of the influence of money injections on risk taking in football clubs
    Franck, E.; Lang, M.
  • Financial fair play in European club football: what is it all about?
    Franck, E.
  • The determinants of football match attendance revisited: empirical evidence from the Spanish football league
    García, J.; Rodríguez, P.
  • Tests of the generalizability of Altman's bankruptcy prediction model
    Grice, J.S.; Ingram, R.W.
  • Subjectivity and the weighting of performance measures: evidence from a balanced scorecard
    Ittner, C.D.; Larcker, D.F.; Meyer, M.W.
  • The use of multiple discriminant analysis in the assessment of the going‐concern status of an audit client
    Koh, H.C.; Killough, L.N.
  • Going concern prediction using data mining techniques
    Koh, H.; Low, C.
  • The beautiful game? An econometric study of why people watch football
    Kuypers, T.
  • Promoting competition or preventing it? A competition law analysis of UEFA's financial fair play rules
    Long, C.
  • Welfare economics of ‘Financial Fair Play’ in a sports league with benefactor owners
    Madden, P.
  • Predicting going concern opinion with data mining
    Martens, D.; Bruynseels, L.; Baesens, B.; Willekens, M.; Vanthienen, J.
  • How big a problem is too big to fail? A review of Gary Stern and Ron Feldman's too big to fail: the hazards of bank bailouts
    Mishkin, F.S.
  • A multivariate analysis of the auditor's going-concern opinion decision
    Mutchler, J.
  • Broadcasting and team sports
    Noll, R.G.
  • Financial ratios and the probabilistic prediction of bankruptcy
    Ohlson, J.A.
  • Vertical restraints in soccer: financial fair play and the English Premier League
    Peeters, T.; Szymanski, S.
  • Financial fair play in European football
    Peeters, T.; Szymanski, S.
  • Possibilities of the Altman Zeta model application to Czech firms
    Pitrová, K.
  • A holistic performance assessment of English premier league football clubs 1992-2013
    Plumley, D.; Wilson, R.; Shibli, S.
  • The unintended consequence of Financial Fair Play: an examination of competitive balance across five European football leagues
    Plumley, D.; Ramchandani, G.; Wilson, R.
  • Performance ratios for managerial decision‐making in a growing firm
    Ponikvar, N.; Tajnikar, M.; Pušnik, K.
  • UEFA financial fair play: the curse of regulation
    Preuss, H.; Haugen, K.; Schubert, M.
  • A longitudinal and comparative analysis of competitive balance in five European football leagues
    Ramchandani, G.; Plumley, D.; Boyes, S.; Wilson, R.
  • Insolvency in French soccer: the case of payment failure
    Scelles, N.; Szymanski, S.; Dermit-Richard, N.
  • Soft budget constraints in professional football
    Storm, R.K.; Nielsen, K.
  • Financial Ratio Analysis of the electric power industry
    Sueyoshi, T.
  • The premier league TV deal - master and servant
  • Fair is foul: a critical analysis of UEFA financial fair play
    Szymanski, S.
  • The relationship between ownership structure and club performance in the English Premier League
    Wilson, R.; Plumley, D.; Ramchandani, G.
  • Parachute payments in English football: softening the landing or distorting the balance?
    Wilson, R.; Ramchandani, G.; Plumley, D.
  • Challenging parachute payments and unmasking English football's finances
    Wilson, R.; Plumley, D.; Mondal, S.; Parnell, D.
  • Methodological issues related to the estimation of financial distress prediction models
    Zmijewski, M.