Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Book Review: Being Nuclear: Africans and the Global Uranium Trade

Book Review: Being Nuclear: Africans and the Global Uranium Trade 124 cultural geographies 20(1) nor explanatory’ (p. 106) – his text seems at times to present a too-tidy argument about the con- temporary dominance of pedestrianism. Still, the value of a book like this is precisely in raising important questions, rather than neces- sarily settling them. In this sense, Rights of Passage is a stunning success. Bruce D’Arcus Miami University, USA Being Nuclear: Africans and the Global Uranium Trade. By Gabrielle Hecht. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press. 2012. xx + 452 pp. $29.95, £20.95 hardback. ISBN: 9780262017268. Some books are better read from the end. Such is the case of historian Gabrielle Hecht’s spectacular opus on African uranium: its conclusive methodological appendix gives detailed information on the tour de force that underlies the book’s research. Based on 138 interviews and the analysis of about 50,000 pages of archives collected in nine countries on four continents (and sometimes saved from termites), the book was 15 years in the making. The appendix provides illuminating insights on the difficulties and serendipities that any researcher on uranium and other nuclear topics may encounter. In her book, Hecht analyzes the significance of African uranium after the Second World War on two different scales. The first part of the book critically engages with the constitution of a global uranium market by using Michel Callon’s framework on market devices: how was such a strategic material transformed into a tradable commodity? And what was the role of African countries in this development? By drawing on public and corporate archives (e.g., Rio Tinto’s Rössing mine in Namibia), Hecht makes a convincing case for the absolute conventionality of uranium prices, flows and trading contracts, and their absolute sensitivity to political influence – whether it be in the con- text of the Cold War or decolonization struggles. The second part of the book dissects the local consequences of uranium mining in Madagascar, Gabon, Namibia and South Africa, with a specific emphasis on workers’ health. Those very good case studies convey a plurality of voices and points of view, not eschewing the silenced voices and contaminated bodies of the African mine workers. Hecht’s theoretical argument seeks to bring together the global uranium trade with local mining practices (each topic could have been the subject of a stand-alone book) by showing how they express and respond to uranium’s contested and shifting ‘nuclearity’. Nuclearity is a ‘techno- political category’ (p. 14) that distributes and classifies things, people and situations according to their perceived ‘nuclear’ ontology. Hecht demonstrates that African uranium has been, in various times and places and depending on social and political actors’ strategies, either treated as a nuclear material, or as a most banal ore, with huge political, economic and public health implications. Sensitive to the specificities of space and time, the book’s STS approach avoids the twin pitfalls of naturalizing/ objectifying uranium; or endowing it with the kind of chthonian agency, that a vital materialist approach might have pursued. In this, Hecht’s approach is thoroughly political and convincing. I have two slight reservations about this important and stimulating book. The volume’s structure and chapter numbering and naming are somewhat confusing: a clearer frame would have been helpful to make sense of the high density of information. Second, the conclusive chapter is frustrat- ing, as it does not conclude anything really. We do not know, in the end, what to make of the heu- ristic power of ‘nuclearity’ but arguably this is precisely in the nature of its innate open-endedness – and its threat. Romain j. Garcier Université de Lyon - Ecole normale supérieur http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Cultural Geographies SAGE

Book Review: Being Nuclear: Africans and the Global Uranium Trade

Cultural Geographies , Volume 20 (1): 1 – Jan 1, 2013
Download PDF
1 page

Loading next page...
 
/lp/sage/book-review-being-nuclear-africans-and-the-global-uranium-trade-xYUYFyOh8d

References (0)

References for this paper are not available at this time. We will be adding them shortly, thank you for your patience.

Publisher
SAGE
Copyright
© The Author(s) 2013
ISSN
1474-4740
eISSN
1477-0881
DOI
10.1177/1474474012462536
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

124 cultural geographies 20(1) nor explanatory’ (p. 106) – his text seems at times to present a too-tidy argument about the con- temporary dominance of pedestrianism. Still, the value of a book like this is precisely in raising important questions, rather than neces- sarily settling them. In this sense, Rights of Passage is a stunning success. Bruce D’Arcus Miami University, USA Being Nuclear: Africans and the Global Uranium Trade. By Gabrielle Hecht. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press. 2012. xx + 452 pp. $29.95, £20.95 hardback. ISBN: 9780262017268. Some books are better read from the end. Such is the case of historian Gabrielle Hecht’s spectacular opus on African uranium: its conclusive methodological appendix gives detailed information on the tour de force that underlies the book’s research. Based on 138 interviews and the analysis of about 50,000 pages of archives collected in nine countries on four continents (and sometimes saved from termites), the book was 15 years in the making. The appendix provides illuminating insights on the difficulties and serendipities that any researcher on uranium and other nuclear topics may encounter. In her book, Hecht analyzes the significance of African uranium after the Second World War on two different scales. The first part of the book critically engages with the constitution of a global uranium market by using Michel Callon’s framework on market devices: how was such a strategic material transformed into a tradable commodity? And what was the role of African countries in this development? By drawing on public and corporate archives (e.g., Rio Tinto’s Rössing mine in Namibia), Hecht makes a convincing case for the absolute conventionality of uranium prices, flows and trading contracts, and their absolute sensitivity to political influence – whether it be in the con- text of the Cold War or decolonization struggles. The second part of the book dissects the local consequences of uranium mining in Madagascar, Gabon, Namibia and South Africa, with a specific emphasis on workers’ health. Those very good case studies convey a plurality of voices and points of view, not eschewing the silenced voices and contaminated bodies of the African mine workers. Hecht’s theoretical argument seeks to bring together the global uranium trade with local mining practices (each topic could have been the subject of a stand-alone book) by showing how they express and respond to uranium’s contested and shifting ‘nuclearity’. Nuclearity is a ‘techno- political category’ (p. 14) that distributes and classifies things, people and situations according to their perceived ‘nuclear’ ontology. Hecht demonstrates that African uranium has been, in various times and places and depending on social and political actors’ strategies, either treated as a nuclear material, or as a most banal ore, with huge political, economic and public health implications. Sensitive to the specificities of space and time, the book’s STS approach avoids the twin pitfalls of naturalizing/ objectifying uranium; or endowing it with the kind of chthonian agency, that a vital materialist approach might have pursued. In this, Hecht’s approach is thoroughly political and convincing. I have two slight reservations about this important and stimulating book. The volume’s structure and chapter numbering and naming are somewhat confusing: a clearer frame would have been helpful to make sense of the high density of information. Second, the conclusive chapter is frustrat- ing, as it does not conclude anything really. We do not know, in the end, what to make of the heu- ristic power of ‘nuclearity’ but arguably this is precisely in the nature of its innate open-endedness – and its threat. Romain j. Garcier Université de Lyon - Ecole normale supérieur

Journal

Cultural Geographies – SAGE

Published: Jan 1, 2013

There are no references for this article.