Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Expansive and extractive networks of Web3

Expansive and extractive networks of Web3 The self-proclaimed usurper of Web 2.0, Web3 quickly became the center of attention. Not long ago, the public discourse was saturated with projects, promises, and peculiarities of Web3. Now the spotlight has swung around to focus on the many faults, failures, and frauds of Web3. The cycles of technological trends and investment bubbles seem to be accelerating in such a way as to escape any attempt at observing them in motion before they crash, and then everybody moves on to the next thing. Importantly, Web3 was not an anomaly or curiosity in the broader tech industry. It articulates patterns that existed before Web3 and will exist after. Web3 should be understood as a case study of innovation within the dominant model of Silicon Valley venture capitalism. Our focus in this article is on understanding how the movement around Web3 formed through an interplay between (1) normative concepts and contestations related to ideas of “decentralization” and (2) political economic interests and operations related to the dynamics of fictitious capital. By offering a critical analysis of Web3, our goal is also to show how any even potentially progressive (or as we call them “expansive”) forms of Web3 development struggle for success, recognition, and attention due to the wild excesses of hype and investment devoted to “extractive” forms of Web3. In the process, they provide us a better view of how different arrangements of technopolitics can exist at the same time, side-by-side, in complicated ways. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Big Data & Society SAGE

Expansive and extractive networks of Web3

Sadowski, Jathan; Beegle, Kaitlin
Big Data & Society , Volume 10 (1): 1 – Jan 1, 2023
Download PDF
14 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/sage/expansive-and-extractive-networks-of-web3-Uxm0NYBvli
Publisher
SAGE
Copyright
© The Author(s) 2023
ISSN
2053-9517
eISSN
2053-9517
DOI
10.1177/20539517231159629
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

The self-proclaimed usurper of Web 2.0, Web3 quickly became the center of attention. Not long ago, the public discourse was saturated with projects, promises, and peculiarities of Web3. Now the spotlight has swung around to focus on the many faults, failures, and frauds of Web3. The cycles of technological trends and investment bubbles seem to be accelerating in such a way as to escape any attempt at observing them in motion before they crash, and then everybody moves on to the next thing. Importantly, Web3 was not an anomaly or curiosity in the broader tech industry. It articulates patterns that existed before Web3 and will exist after. Web3 should be understood as a case study of innovation within the dominant model of Silicon Valley venture capitalism. Our focus in this article is on understanding how the movement around Web3 formed through an interplay between (1) normative concepts and contestations related to ideas of “decentralization” and (2) political economic interests and operations related to the dynamics of fictitious capital. By offering a critical analysis of Web3, our goal is also to show how any even potentially progressive (or as we call them “expansive”) forms of Web3 development struggle for success, recognition, and attention due to the wild excesses of hype and investment devoted to “extractive” forms of Web3. In the process, they provide us a better view of how different arrangements of technopolitics can exist at the same time, side-by-side, in complicated ways.

Journal

Big Data & Society – SAGE

Published: Jan 1, 2023

Keywords: Web3; blockchain; decentralization; fictitious capital; venture capital; political economy

References

  • State of crypto: an overview report
  • DeFi: Shadow Banking 2.0?
    Allen, HJ
  • It’s time to build
    Andreessen, M
  • Bitcoin whale
    Banton, C
  • Attracting early stage investors: Evidence from a randomized field experiment
    Bernstein, S; Korteweg, A; Laws, K
  • Decentralisation: A multidisciplinary perspective
    Bodó, B; Brekke, JK; Hoepman, J-H
  • The internet is just investment banking now
    Bogost, I
  • The sociology of expectations in science and technology
    Borup, M; Brown, N; Konrad, K
  • Hacker-engineers and their economies: The political economy of decentralised networks and ‘cryptoeconomics’
    Brekke, JK
  • The meaning of decentralization
    Buterin, V
  • Self-sovereignty for refugees? The contested horizons of digital identity
    Cheesman, M
  • Capitol coin
    Claypool, R
  • Veni vidi VC – The backend of the digital economy and its political making
    Cooiman, F
  • Utopia of abstraction: Digital organizations and the promise of sovereignty
    Corballis, T; Soar, M
  • A simple guide to the Web3 stack
    Dempsey, C; Wang, A; Mart, J
  • The New York Times has a crypto blindspot
    Diehl, S
  • Crypto fund III
    Dixon, C; Haun, K; Yahya, A
  • The social life of bitcoin
    Dodd, N
  • ‘The interface of the future’: Mixed reality, intimate data and imagined temporalities
    Egliston, B; Carter, M
  • The power of nobodies: Why community matters
    Foreman, R
  • Deception, exploited workers, and cash handouts
    Guo, E; Renaldi, A
  • Failure of FTX crypto exchange will have huge implications, MPs hear
    Hern, A
  • Blockchain imperialism in the pacific
    Jutel, O
  • Do libertarians dream of electric coins? The material embeddedness of bitcoin
    Karlstrøm, H
  • Bored Ape Yacht Club creator raises $450 million to build an NFT metaverse
    Kastrenakes, J
  • Great protocol politics
    Khanna, P; Srinivasan, BS
  • Building a venture capital market in Vietnam: Diffusion of a neoliberal market strategy to a socialist state
    Klingler-Vidra, R
  • When venture capital is patient capital: Seed funding as a source of patient capital for high-growth companies
    Klingler-Vidra, R
  • Remembering netscape: The birth of the web
    Lashinsky, A
  • Venture capital’s role in financing innovation: What we know and how much we still need to learn
    Lerner, J; Nanda, R
  • FTX’s balance sheet was bad
    Levine, M
  • Big hires, big money and a D.C. Blitz: A bold plan to dominate crypto
    Lipton, E; Wakabayashi, D; Livni, E
  • My first impressions of Web3
    Marlinspike, M
  • Crypto evangelists promise Web3 will be a truly free and democratic internet—but it’s failing to live up to that hype
    Marx, P
  • ‘When perhaps the real problem is money itself!’: The practical materiality of bitcoin
    Maurer, B; Nelms, TC; Swartz, L
  • The pandemic sparked a golden age of crypto scams
    McKenzie, B; Silverman, B
  • Funding starts to cascade into Web3 startups
    Metinko, C
  • The meme hustler
    Morozov, E
  • Critique of techno-feudal reason
    Morozov, E
  • Web3: A map in search of territory
    Morozov, E
  • What would Karl Marx think about crypto?
    Munster, B
  • Decentralising data governance: Decentralised autonomous organisations (DAOs) as data trusts
    Nabben, K
  • New tech v. new deal: Fintech as a systemic phenomenon
    Omarova, ST
  • The NFT ecosystem is a complete disaster
    Ongweso, E
  • Andreessen Horowitz goes ham on crypto with a new $2.2B fund
    Pardes, A
  • Chris Dixon thinks Web3 is the future of the internet—is it?
    Patel, N; Dixon, C
  • Meet the new crypto-communists
    Pimentel, B
  • The social construction of facts and artefacts: Or how the sociology of science and the sociology of technology might benefit each other
    Pinch, TJ; Bijker, WE
  • The metaverse land rush is an illusion
    Ravenscraft, E
  • Selling smartness: Corporate narratives and the smart city as a sociotechnical imaginary
    Sadowski, J; Bendor, R
  • Decentralization: An incomplete ambition
    Schneider, N
  • Meet the ‘crypto caucus’: the US lawmakers defending digital coins
    Stacey, K
  • What was bitcoin, what will it be? The techno-economic imaginaries of a new money technology
    Swartz, L
  • The Third Web
  • Comparing technological hype cycles: Towards a theory
    van Lente, H; Spitters, C; Peine, A
  • Towards a digital pluriverse
  • Mine the gap: Bitcoin and the maintenance of trustlessness
    Vidan, G; Lehdonvirta, V
  • Will the crypto crash derail the next web revolution?
    Waters, R; Murphy, H; Chipolina, S
  • Property values
    Woodall, R
  • Initial coin offerings: Linking technology and financialization
    Zook, M; Grote, MH