Access the full text.
Sign up today, get DeepDyve free for 14 days.
Loading next page...
/lp/sage/neither-the-magic-bullet-nor-the-big-bad-wolf-a-systematic-review-of-KlqcNw0dZb
References (118)
-
A. Barak, O. Pfersmann (2017)
Les juges comme gardiens de la constitution sur l’acte de jugerCités, 69
-
E. Jeuland (2018)
Towards a new court management?Peking University Law Journal, 6
-
R. Dekker, Juan Contreras, A. Meijer (2019)
The Living Lab as a Methodology for Public Administration Research: a Systematic Literature Review of its Applications in the Social SciencesInternational Journal of Public Administration, 43
-
P. Hupe (2019)
Research Handbook on Street-Level Bureaucracy -
C. Engel, Keren Weinshall (2020)
Manna from Heaven for Judges: Judges’ Reaction to a Quasi‐Random Reduction in CaseloadJournal of Empirical Legal Studies, 17
-
C. Pollitt, G. Bouckaert (2017)
Public Management Reform. A Comparative Analysis - Into the Age of Austeriy -
T. Rambaud (2014)
Introduction au droit comparé -
10.1504/IJMBS.2018.093876
-
C. Pollitt, G. Bouckaert (2017)
Public Management Reform A Comparative Analysis Into The Age of Austerity 4th Edition, 392
-
Hans Hansen, K. Lundberg, Liv Syltevik (2018)
Digitalization, Street‐Level Bureaucracy and Welfare Users' ExperiencesSocial Policy & Administration, 52
-
K. Beyens, V. Scheirs (2010)
Encounters of a different kind: Social inquiry and sentencing in BelgiumPunishment & Society, 12
-
Tom Christensen, Per Lægreid (2010)
Increased Complexity in Public Organizations — the Challenges of Combining NPM and Post-NPM -
Kerstin Jacobsson, Ylva Wallinder, Ida Seing (2020)
Street-level bureaucrats under new managerialism: a comparative study of agency cultures and caseworker role identities in two welfare state bureaucraciesJournal of Professions and Organization
-
Eric Nachtergaele, A. Piraux (2017)
Revaloriser et moderniser notre justice -
Andreas Lienhard, Daniel Kettiger (2018)
Vers un management adéquat pour la justice -
(2011)
Le nouveau management et l'indépendance des juges -
D. Cowan, E. Hitchings (2007)
`Pretty Boring Stuff': District Judges and Housing Possession ProceedingsSocial & Legal Studies, 16
-
Frédéric Bouhon, Quentin Pironnet (2017)
Le pouvoir judiciaire et l'équilibre des pouvoirs : réflexions à propos des récentes réformes, 29
-
S. Osborne (2006)
The New Public Governance? 1Public Management Review, 8
-
Robert Waxweiler (2017)
Le regroupement des justices de paix. Vers la disparition d’un modèle -
Jesús Palomo, Cristina Figueroa-Domecq, Pilar Laguna (2017)
Women, peace and security state-of-art: a bibliometric analysis in social sciences based on SCOPUS databaseScientometrics, 113
-
I. Rovenskaya (2014)
Bids in the Field of Water-ManagementJournal of Russian Law, 2
-
Cyrus Tata (2007)
Sentencing as Craftwork and the Binary Epistemologies of the Discretionary Decision ProcessSocial & Legal Studies, 16
-
Christian Mouhanna, B. Bastard (2010)
Procureurs et substituts : l'évolution du système de production des décisions pénales, 74
-
Aharon Barak, Otto Pfersmann (2017)
Les juges comme gardiens de la Constitution sur l’acte de jugerChemie Ingenieur Technik, 69
-
E. Erasmus (2014)
The use of street-level bureaucracy theory in health policy analysis in low- and middle-income countries: a meta-ethnographic synthesis.Health policy and planning, 29 Suppl 3
-
Joël Ficet (2011)
Trajectoires de réforme de la carte judiciaire et managérialisation de l'État. Analyse comparée des politiques de territorialisation de la Justice en France et en Belgique, 18
-
Reinventing Government, D. Osborne (1993)
Reinventing governmentNature, 365
-
10.2307/j.ctt1t89bw0.5
-
J. Tender (1969)
Revue de Science criminelle et de Droit pénal comparéThe Military Law and the Law of War Review
-
W. Voorberg, V. Bekkers, L. Tummers (2014)
A Systematic Review of Co-Creation and Co-Production: Embarking on the social innovation journeyPublic Management Review, 17
-
Élisa Chelle (2011)
Une politique de récompense dans la haute magistrature : le cas de la prime de rendement -
Philip Langbroek (2008)
Entre responsabilisation et indépendance des magistrats : la réorganisation du système judiciaire des Pays-Bas, 125
-
Cécile Vigour (2017)
Nouveau référentiel gestionnaire ou nouveau modèle de justice ? Les réformes belges depuis 2013 -
E. Brodkin (2011)
Policy Work: Street-Level Organizations Under New ManagerialismJournal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 21
-
T. Rambaud (2014)
Chapitre II. La tradition juridique de common law -
C. Allison (2013)
Le droit et l'administration de la justice face aux instruments managériaux -
Tracy Eells, C. Showalter, Jackson St (1994)
Work-related stress in American trial judges.The Bulletin of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law, 22 1
-
Michael Siciliano (2017)
Professional Networks and Street-Level PerformanceThe American Review of Public Administration, 47
-
C. Ham, Michael Hill (1984)
The Policy Process in the Modern Capitalist State -
J. Reynaud (1989)
Les règles du jeu : l'action collective et la régulation sociale -
J. Torfing, L. Andersen, C. Greve, K. Klausen (2020)
New Public GovernancePublic Governance Paradigms
-
C. Engel, Keren Margel (2020)
Manna from Heaven for Judges – Judges’ Reaction to a Quasi-Random Reduction in CaseloadLitigation & Procedure eJournal
-
Matthew Kleiman, Richard Schauffler, Brian Ostrom, Cynthia Lee (2018)
Weighted caseload: a critical element of modern court administrationInternational Journal of the Legal Profession, 26
-
T. Guimaraes, Adalmir Gomes, P. Correia, Inés Oliveira, Tânia Piazentin (2017)
Role Conflict and Role Ambiguity in the Work of Judges: The Perceptions of Portuguese Judges -
L. Taskin, Pierre Gomez (2015)
Articuler la théorie de la régulation sociale et l'approche conventionnaliste en gestion pour comprendre l'échec d'un projet de changement organisationnel. Illustration par la mise en place du télétravail dans deux administrations publiques belges, 14
-
Sandrine Mathias, P. Daigle, K. Dancause, T. Gadais (2019)
Forest bathing: a narrative review of the effects on health for outdoor and environmental education use in CanadaJournal of Outdoor and Environmental Education, 23
-
M. Lipsky (1983)
Street-Level Bureaucracy: The Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Service -
E. Mak (2008)
The European Judicial Organisation in a New Paradigm: The Influence of Principles of New Public Management on the Organisation of the European CourtsEuropean Economics: Political Economy & Public Economics eJournal
-
W. Hendrikx (2021)
Managerialism and Its Consequences for Professional Identity: A Comparative Analysis of GPs and Secondary School TeachersAdministration & Society, 53
-
Jean-Paul Jean (2008)
Le chantier ouvert des réformes de la justice, 125
-
N. Fielding (2011)
Judges and Their WorkSocial & Legal Studies, 20
-
M. Sabbe, Nathalie Schiffino, Stéphane Moyson (2021)
Walking on Thin Ice: How and Why Frontline Officers Cope With Managerialism, Accountability, and Risk in Probation ServicesAdministration & Society, 53
-
M. Fishbein, I. Ajzen (2009)
Predicting and Changing Behavior: The Reasoned Action Approach -
P. Sabatier (1986)
Top-Down and Bottom-Up Approaches to Implementation Research: a Critical Analysis and Suggested SynthesisJournal of Public Policy, 6
-
10.2307/3381012
-
Steven Maynard-Moody, Michael Musheno, D. Palumbo (1990)
Street-Wise Social Policy: Resolving the Dilemma of Street-Level Influence and Successful ImplementationPolitical Research Quarterly, 43
-
J. Danet (2020)
La prudence du juge à l'épreuve des organisations judiciaires -
J. Raine, M. Willson (1995)
New public management and criminal justicePublic Money & Management, 15
-
B. Haeperen (2012)
Que sont les principes du New Public Management devenus -
T. Rambaud (2014)
Introduction au droit comparé : les grandes traditions juridiques dans le monde -
Evert Vedung (2015)
Autonomy and street-level bureaucrats’ coping strategiesNordic Journal of Studies in Educational Policy, 2015
-
J. Hersant (2017)
Patronage and Rationalization: Reform to Criminal Procedure and the Lower Courts in ChileLaw & Social Inquiry, 42
-
L. Tummers, V. Bekkers, E. Vink, Michael Musheno (2015)
Coping During Public Service Delivery: A Conceptualization and Systematic Review of the LiteraturePolitical Behavior: Cognition
-
G. Terssac (2012)
La théorie de la régulation sociale : repères introductifs -
Tânia Keinert, Claudete Silva (1993)
Reinventing government: how the entrepreneurial spirit is transforming the public sectorRae-revista De Administracao De Empresas, 33
-
T. Evans (2011)
Professionals, Managers and Discretion: Critiquing Street-Level BureaucracyBritish Journal of Social Work, 41
-
Barbara Truffin (2007)
Les juges de paix belges et la mutation des modèles de justice civile, 66
-
Christian Mouhanna, B. Bastard (2011)
Deux justices au banc d'essai: Comparer les mondes judiciaires pour analyser l'évolution des modèles de justiceDeviance Et Societe, 35
-
Mork Cannon (2005)
INNOVATION IN THE ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE, 1969-1981: AN OVERVIEWPolicy Studies Journal, 10
-
(1981)
Reflets et Perspectives de la vie EconomiqueRecherches économiques de Louvain
-
C. Dallara, Alice Lacchei (2021)
Street-level Bureaucrats and Coping Mechanisms.The Unexpected Role of Italian Judges in Asylum Policy ImplementationSouth European Society and Politics, 26
-
Adrian Ritz, Gene Brewer, O. Neumann (2016)
Public Service Motivation: A Systematic Literature Review and OutlookPublic Administration Review, 76
-
Steven Maynard-Moody, Michael Musheno (2012)
Social Equities and Inequities in Practice: Street-Level Workers as Agents and PragmatistsPublic Administration Review, 72
-
Fergal Connolly, D. Byrne, S. Lydon, C. Walsh, P. O’Connor (2017)
Barriers and facilitators related to the implementation of a physiological track and trigger system: A systematic review of the qualitative evidenceInternational Journal for Quality in Health Care, 29
-
Gitte Harrits, M. Møller (2014)
Prevention at the Front Line: How home nurses, pedagogues, and teachers transform public worry into decisions on special effortsPublic Management Review, 16
-
M. Rowe (2020)
Book review: Research Handbook on Street-level Bureaucracy: The Ground Floor of Government in ContextTeaching Public Administration, 38
-
Christian Mouhanna (2015)
Le New Public Management et ses limites dans les politiques publiques de justice pénale. Le cas de l’exécution des peines en France -
Danielle Morin (2011)
Serving as magistrate at the FrenchCour des comptes: Navigating between tradition and modernityAccounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 24
-
Stefaan Voet (2014)
Belgium's New Specialized JudiciaryRussian Law Journal, 2
-
J. Reynaud, D. Reynaud, P. Bernoux (1990)
Les règles du jeu -
M. Visser, R. Schouteten, J. Dikkers (2019)
Controlling the Courts: New Public Management and the Dutch JudiciaryJustice System Journal, 40
-
K. Beyens, Veerle Scheirs (2010)
Encounters of a different kindPunishment & Society, 12
-
Margaret Ferley (1993)
The American Review of Public AdministrationSerials Review, 19
-
J. Yepes-Nuñez, G. Úrrutia, M. Romero-García, S. Alonso-Fernández (2021)
The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews.Revista espanola de cardiologia, 74 9
-
J. Reynaud (2003)
Réflexion I. Régulation de contrôle, régulation autonome, régulation conjointe -
N. Gestel, Marlot Kuiper, W. Hendrikx (2019)
Changed Roles and Strategies of Professionals in the (co)Production of Public ServicesAdministrative Sciences
-
B. Bastard, D. Delvaux, Christian Mouhanna, F. Schoenaers (2015)
Vitesse ou précipitation ? La question du temps dans le traitement des affaires pénales en France et en Belgique, 90
-
P. Hupe, Michael Hill (2007)
STREET-LEVEL BUREAUCRACY AND PUBLIC ACCOUNTABILITYPublic Administration, 85
-
Steven Maynard-Moody, Michael Musheno (2000)
State Agent or Citizen Agent: Two Narratives of DiscretionJournal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 10
-
E. Brodkin (2012)
Reflections on Street‐Level Bureaucracy: Past, Present, and FuturePublic Administration Review, 72
-
M. O'Neill, S. Booth, J. Lamb (2018)
Using NVivo for Literature Reviews: The Eight Step Pedagogy (N7+1)The Qualitative Report, 23
-
C. Haddad (2020)
Developing Management Skills for JudgesInternational Journal for Court Administration, 11
-
T. Guimarães, Adalmir Gomes, Pedro Correia, Inês Oliveira, Tânia Piazentin (2017)
Conflitos e ambiguidades de papéis no trabalho de juízes: as percepções de juízes portugueses, 51
-
I. Taylor (2007)
Discretion and Control in EducationEducational Management Administration & Leadership, 35
-
K. Mack, S. Anleu (2007)
`Getting Through the List': Judgecraft and Legitimacy in the Lower CourtsSocial & Legal Studies, 16
-
Émilie Biland, Hélène Steinmetz (2017)
Are Judges Street-Level Bureaucrats? Evidence from French and Canadian Family CourtsLaw & Social Inquiry, 42
-
L. Kørnøv, Jie Zhang, P. Christensen (2015)
The influence of street level bureaucracy on the implementation of Strategic Environmental AssessmentJournal of Environmental Planning and Management, 58
-
L. Tummers (2016)
The Relationship between Coping and Job PerformanceManagement of Innovation eJournal
-
Nicolas d'Hervé (2015)
La magistrature face au management judiciaire -
(2018)
European judicial systems CEPEJ Evaluation Report 2020 Evaluation cycle -
P. Booth (2007)
The control of Discretion: Planning and the Common-Law traditionPlanning Theory, 6
-
J. Commaille, Benoist Hurel (2011)
La réforme de la justice française. Un enjeu entre instrumentalisation et démocratie -
S. Halliday, Nicola Burns, N. Hutton, F. McNeill, Cyrus Tata (2009)
Street-Level Bureaucracy, Interprofessional Relations, and Coping Mechanisms: A Study of Criminal Justice Social Workers in the Sentencing ProcessPublic Choice: Analysis of Collective Decision-Making eJournal
-
D. Moher, A. Liberati, J. Tetzlaff, D. Altman (2009)
Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statementThe BMJ, 339
-
Cécile Vigour (2008)
Politiques et magistrats face aux réformes de la justice en Belgique, France et Italie, 125
-
10.3917/dec.terss.2003.01.0103
-
N. Cohen, Niva Golan‐Nadir (2020)
Why do street‐level bureaucrats risk themselves for others? The case of Israeli police officersAustralian Journal of Public Administration, 79
-
J. Raine (2005)
Courts, Sentencing and Justice in a Changing Political and Managerial ContextPublic Money & Management, 25
-
Les ordinaux (2020)
CHAPITRE IIKirakos Ganjakec'i (XIIIe siecle). Histoire d'Armenie
-
L. Borrelli, A. Lindberg (2018)
The creativity of coping: alternative tales of moral dilemmas among migration control officers, 4
-
Nanna Mik-Meyer (2018)
Organizational Professionalism: Social Workers Negotiating Tools of NPMProfessions and Professionalism, 8
-
M. Page, J. McKenzie, P. Bossuyt, I. Boutron, T. Hoffmann, C. Mulrow, Larissa Shamseer, J. Tetzlaff, E. Akl, S. Brennan, R. Chou, Julie Glanville, J. Grimshaw, A. Hrõbjartsson, M. Lalu, Tianjing Li, E. Loder, E. Mayo-Wilson, Steve McDonald, L. McGuinness, L. Stewart, James Thomas, A. Tricco, V. Welch, P. Whiting, D. Moher (2020)
The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviewsSystematic Reviews, 10
-
Cécile Vigour (2006)
Justice : l'introduction d'une rationalité managériale comme euphémisation des enjeux politiques -
A. Vauchez (2008)
Le chiffre dans le « gouvernement » de la justice, 125
-
Hélène Colombet, Alice Gouttefangeas (2013)
La qualité des décisions de justice. Quels critères -
U. Nothdurfter, K. Hermans (2018)
Meeting (or not) at the street level? A literature review on street‐level research in public management, social policy and social workInternational Journal of Social Welfare, 27
-
J. Heijden, Johanna Kuhlmann (2017)
Studying Incremental Institutional Change: A Systematic and Critical Meta‐Review of the Literature from 2005 to 2015Policy Studies Journal, 45
- Publisher
- SAGE
- Copyright
- © The Author(s) 2023
- ISSN
- 0095-3997
- eISSN
- 1552-3039
- DOI
- 10.1177/00953997231157748
- Publisher site
- See Article on Publisher Site
Abstract
How do frontline judges perceive managerial reforms, and how do they cope with them? We relied on concepts from street-level bureaucracy to systematically review the effects of managerial techniques on frontline judges in 35 studies. We find that judges’ attitudes toward managerialization are more heterogeneous than might be anticipated. Beyond facing an increasing caseload, judges are pressed to reduce treatment times and costs as well as to play managerial roles. Judges’ mechanisms to cope with pressures include rationing, prioritizing, and routinizing. While managerialization is a solution to the increasing caseload, it might well affect the quality of justice.
Journal
Administration & Society – SAGE
Published: May 1, 2023
Keywords: coping mechanism; discretion; frontline judge; new public management; street-level bureaucracy; systematic review