Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Theories of Political Ecology: Monopoly Capital Against People and the Planet

Theories of Political Ecology: Monopoly Capital Against People and the Planet This article engages with and critiques dominant theories of political ecology. It takes the theory of ecologically unequal exchange (EUE) as the framework of critique. It assesses the claims of “fossil capitalism,” eco-modernism, extractivism, and degrowth, as well as the theories of “post-development.” It finds that with the exception of degrowth, none of them take imperialism or the global history of accumulation sufficiently seriously, and either displace transformative obligations wholly onto the South or adopt a framework which centers merely the agency of the Northern working class or a class-blind movement of movements. Instead, it proposes modifications of EUE based on the polarized nature of accumulation and waste production and distribution, and neocolonialism. It uses that framework to identify the antisystemic role of nature-reliant peripheral semi-proletarian classes, and from there reopens the debate on appropriate-scale industrialization along with ecological transformations of agriculture as paths to development in the twenty-first century. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Agrarian South: Journal of Political Economy SAGE

Theories of Political Ecology: Monopoly Capital Against People and the Planet

Ajl, Max
Agrarian South: Journal of Political Economy , Volume 12 (1): 39 – Mar 1, 2023
Download PDF
39 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/sage/theories-of-political-ecology-monopoly-capital-against-people-and-the-5gPDv8DP0r
Publisher
SAGE
Copyright
© 2023 Centre for Agrarian Research and Education for South (CARES)
ISSN
2277-9760
eISSN
2321-0281
DOI
10.1177/22779760221145232
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

This article engages with and critiques dominant theories of political ecology. It takes the theory of ecologically unequal exchange (EUE) as the framework of critique. It assesses the claims of “fossil capitalism,” eco-modernism, extractivism, and degrowth, as well as the theories of “post-development.” It finds that with the exception of degrowth, none of them take imperialism or the global history of accumulation sufficiently seriously, and either displace transformative obligations wholly onto the South or adopt a framework which centers merely the agency of the Northern working class or a class-blind movement of movements. Instead, it proposes modifications of EUE based on the polarized nature of accumulation and waste production and distribution, and neocolonialism. It uses that framework to identify the antisystemic role of nature-reliant peripheral semi-proletarian classes, and from there reopens the debate on appropriate-scale industrialization along with ecological transformations of agriculture as paths to development in the twenty-first century.

Journal

Agrarian South: Journal of Political Economy – SAGE

Published: Mar 1, 2023

Keywords: Agriculture; climate; degrowth; extractivism; imperialism; ecologically unequal exchange

References

  • Extractivism and neoextractivism: Two sides of the same curse
    Acosta, A.
  • Auto-centered development and indigenous technics: Slaheddine el-Amami and Tunisian delinking
    Ajl, M.
  • Auto-centered development and indigenous technics: Slaheddine el-Amami and Tunisian delinking
    Ajl, M.
  • Delinking’s ecological turn: The hidden legacy of Samir Amin
    Ajl, M.
  • Stories about oil and war
    Ajl, M.
  • Does the Arab region have an agrarian question?
    Ajl, M.
  • The green revolution and transversal countermovements: Recovering alternative agronomic imaginaries in Tunisia and India
    Ajl, M.; Sharma, D.
  • The social and natural environment of fossil capitalism
    Altvater, E.
  • A note on the concept of delinking
    Amin, S.
  • Lost and found: Bourgeois dependency theory and the forgotten roots of neodevelopmentalism
    Antunes de Oliveira, F.
  • Human and social values in agroecology: A review
    Bezner Kerr, R.; Liebert, J.; Kansanga, M.; Kpienbaareh, D.
  • The dark side of transformation: Latent risks in contemporary sustainability discourse
    Blythe, J.; Silver, J.; Evans, L.; Armitage, D.; Bennett, N. J.; Moore, M.-L.; Morrison, T. H.; Brown, K.
  • The origins of capitalist development: A critique of neo-Smithian Marxism
    Brenner, R.
  • Por una agenda estratégica de América Latina
    Bruckmann, M.; Dos Santos, T.
  • Half-earth or whole earth? Radical ideas for conservation, and their implications
    Büscher, B.; Fletcher, R.; Brockington, D.; Sandbrook, C.; Adams, W. M.; Campbell, L.; Corson, C.; Dressler, W.; Duffy, R.; Gray, N.
  • Para o conhecimento do problema da erosão do solo na Guiné
    Cabral, A. L.
  • Reassessing pollution haven effect in global value chains
    Duan, Y.; Ji, T.; Yu, T.
  • Marx’s economic manuscripts of 1861–63 and the “concept” of Dependency (A. Yanez, Trans.)
    Dussel, E.; Yanez, A.
  • Degrowth, postdevelopment, and transitions: A preliminary conversation
    Escobar, A.
  • Exploring degrowth policy proposals: A systematic mapping with thematic synthesis
    Fitzpatrick, N.; Parrique, T.; Cosme, I.
  • Marx’s theory of metabolic rift: Classical foundations for environmental sociology
    Foster, J. B.
  • Agriculture and the state system: The rise and decline of national agricultures, 1870 to the present
    Friedmann, H.; McMichael, P.
  • A world in reverse: The political ecology of racial capitalism
    Gill, B. S.
  • Excedente en el desarrollo: Revisión y nueva conceptualización desde los extractivismos
    Gudynas, E.
  • Climate Leninism and revolutionary transition
    Heron, K.; Dean, J.
  • Gunning for Damascus: Anatomy of a U.S. War
    Higgins, P.
  • Resource geographies I: Valuing nature (or not)
    Huber, M.
  • In the empire’s crosshairs
    Koerner, L.
  • The military origins of Soviet industrialization
    Kontorovich, V.
  • From Gandhi to Deendayal: Contradictions of conservative Hindu tendencies in Indian environmental thinking
    Krejčík, J.
  • China imperialism or semi-periphery?
    Li, M.
  • The origins of fossil capital: From water to steam in the British cotton industry
    Malm, A.
  • Seize the means of carbon removal: The political economy of direct air capture
    Malm, A.; Carton, W.
  • Sustainable agrifood systems for a post-growth world
    McGreevy, S. R.; Rupprecht, C. D.; Niles, D.; Wiek, A.; Carolan, M.; Kallis, G.; Kantamaturapoj, K.; Mangnus, A.; Jehlička, P.; Taherzadeh, O.
  • World-systems analysis, globalization, and incorporated comparison
    McMichael, P.
  • Neostructuralism and its class character in the political economy of Bolivia under Evo Morales
    McNelly, A.
  • South–South cooperation or dependency with “Chinese characteristics” in Venezuela?
    Miriam, E.; To, Y.-H.
  • Perspectives on South–South relations: China’s presence in Africa
    Moyo, S.
  • Imperialism and primitive accumulation: Notes on the new scramble for Africa
    Moyo, S.; Yeros, P.; Jha, P.
  • Capitalism, nature, socialism a theoretical introduction
    O’Connor, J.
  • KR Datye: Visionary of a sustainable and equitable future
    Paranjape, S.; Joy, K. J.; Kulkarni, S.
  • The concept of primitive accumulation of capital
    Patnaik, P.
  • Realising climate reparations: Towards a global climate stabilization fund and resilience fund programme for loss and damage in marginalised and former colonised societies
    Perry, K.
  • IPBES-IPCC co-sponsored workshop report on biodiversity and climate change; IPBES and IPCC
    Pörtner, H. O.; Scholes, R. J.; Agard, J.; Archer, E.; Arneth, A.; Bai, X.; Barnes, D.; Burrows, M.; Chan, L.; Cheung, W. L.
  • Towards a conception of socially useful nature
    Prasad, A.
  • Planetary boundaries: Exploring the safe operating space for humanity
    Rockström, J.; Steffen, W.; Noone, K.; Persson, Å.; Chapin, III, F. S.; Lambin, E.; Lenton, T. M.; Scheffer, M.; Folke, C.; Schellnhuber, H.; Nykvist, B.; De Wit, C. A.; Hughes, T.; van der Leeuw, S.; Rodhe, H.; Sörlin, S.; Snyder, P. K.; Costanza, R.; Svedin, U.; Falkenmark, M.; Karlberg, L.; Corell, R. W.; Fabry, V. J.; Hansen, J.; Walker, B.; Liverman, D.; Richardson, K.; Crutzen, P.; Foley, J.
  • How to write about pipelines
  • Toxic uncertainties and epistemic emergence: Understanding pesticides and health in Lao PDR
    Shattuck, A.
  • Popular mobilization and disaster management in Cuba
    Sims, H.; Vogelmann, K.
  • A critique of ecologically unequal exchange theory
    Somerville, P.
  • Who are the victims of low-carbon transitions? Towards a political ecology of climate change mitigation
    Sovacool, B. K.
  • The sun and the scythe: Energy dispossessions and the agrarian question of labor in solar parks
    Stock, R.; Birkenholtz, T.
  • Resource extractivism and alternatives: Latin American perspectives on development
    Svampa, M.
  • Indigenous peoples and biodiversity
    Toledo, V. M.
  • Onward to liberation!—Samir Amin and the study of world historical capitalism
    Valiani, S.
  • Latin America in the climate change negotiations: Exploring the AILAC and ALBA coalitions
    Watts, J.; Depledge, J.
  • A great little man: The shadow of Jair Bolsonaro
    Webber, J. R.
  • Beating the bounds: How does ‘open source’ become a seed commons?
    Wit, M. M. de.
  • A new Bandung in the current crisis
    Yeros, P.