Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

A Critical Overview of Biological FunctionsFunction and Selection

A Critical Overview of Biological Functions: Function and Selection [This chapter focuses on the selected effects theory of function. According to this view, a function of a trait is whatever it was selected for by natural selection or some natural process of selection. I show how the theory plausibly accounts for the explanatory and normative aspects of function. First, if a function of a trait is whatever it was selected for by natural selection, then when one attributes a function to a trait one provides a causal explanation for why the trait currently exists. Second, since the function of a trait is determined by its history rather than current performance, it is easy to see how a trait can have a function that it cannot perform (“dysfunction”). I sketch the somewhat complex historical background of this theory. The theory was actually developed by biologists throughout the twentieth century, and in the 1970s philosophers began to explore it systematically. I survey the major criticisms of the theory and show why they are not compelling. Critics say that it does not really account for the explanatory and normative features of function; that it is inconsistent with the way biologists actually use the term; that there are (real or imaginary) counterexamples; and that it is committed to adaptationism. I close by presenting a new version of the theory, the generalized selected effects theory, which shows how brain structures (such as synapses) can acquire new functions during an individual’s lifetime through a process that is analogous in some ways to natural selection itself.] http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png

A Critical Overview of Biological FunctionsFunction and Selection

Part of the SpringerBriefs in Philosophy Book Series
Garson, Justin
Springer Journals — Mar 31, 2016
Download PDF
32 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/springer-journals/a-critical-overview-of-biological-functions-function-and-selection-DYkyyQ88Wl
Publisher
Springer International Publishing
Copyright
© The Author(s) 2016
ISBN
978-3-319-32018-2
Pages
33 –65
DOI
10.1007/978-3-319-32020-5_3
Publisher site
See Chapter on Publisher Site

Abstract

[This chapter focuses on the selected effects theory of function. According to this view, a function of a trait is whatever it was selected for by natural selection or some natural process of selection. I show how the theory plausibly accounts for the explanatory and normative aspects of function. First, if a function of a trait is whatever it was selected for by natural selection, then when one attributes a function to a trait one provides a causal explanation for why the trait currently exists. Second, since the function of a trait is determined by its history rather than current performance, it is easy to see how a trait can have a function that it cannot perform (“dysfunction”). I sketch the somewhat complex historical background of this theory. The theory was actually developed by biologists throughout the twentieth century, and in the 1970s philosophers began to explore it systematically. I survey the major criticisms of the theory and show why they are not compelling. Critics say that it does not really account for the explanatory and normative features of function; that it is inconsistent with the way biologists actually use the term; that there are (real or imaginary) counterexamples; and that it is committed to adaptationism. I close by presenting a new version of the theory, the generalized selected effects theory, which shows how brain structures (such as synapses) can acquire new functions during an individual’s lifetime through a process that is analogous in some ways to natural selection itself.]

Published: Mar 31, 2016

Keywords: Selected effects theory; Etiological theory; Teleofunctions; Backwards-looking functions; Neural selection; Synapse selection

There are no references for this article.