Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Your rule of law is not mine: rethinking empirical approaches to EU rule of law promotion

Your rule of law is not mine: rethinking empirical approaches to EU rule of law promotion The promotion of the “Rule of Law” is a leading ambition of the EU’s external action (Article 21 TEU). The dominant approach in most policy documents is to define the rule of law in terms of legal and institutional checklists. However, several authors have criticized this “anatomical” approach and have argued for a “sociological” approach. In this paper, I will discuss two empirical models of the rule of law. Most current studies follow the model of the “Rule of Law in Action.” This approach is based on Roscoe Pound’s distinction between the “law in the books” and the “law in action.” I will argue that this conventional approach has several shortcomings. I will therefore introduce an alternative model, based on Eugen Ehrlich’s concept of the “living law.” The principal concern of the “Living Rule of Law” model is not the level of social support but rather the social definition of the rule of law. To assess the strengths and weaknesses of both approaches, I will apply both models in a case study about rule of law reform in a refugee camp on the Thailand–Burma border. It will be concluded that empirical research is essential to evaluate the EU’s external action. Moreover, empirical studies based on the model of the Living Rule of Law support a legal pluralist approach, which focuses on the user perspective of citizens and which recognizes the contested notion of the rule of law across cultural borders. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Asia Europe Journal Springer Journals

Your rule of law is not mine: rethinking empirical approaches to EU rule of law promotion

Hertogh, Marc
Asia Europe Journal , Volume 14 (1) – Sep 24, 2015
Download PDF
17 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/springer-journals/your-rule-of-law-is-not-mine-rethinking-empirical-approaches-to-eu-c9WMkgR0uC
Publisher
Springer Journals
Copyright
Copyright © 2015 by The Author(s)
Subject
Social Sciences; Social Sciences, general; International Economics
ISSN
1610-2932
eISSN
1612-1031
DOI
10.1007/s10308-015-0434-x
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

The promotion of the “Rule of Law” is a leading ambition of the EU’s external action (Article 21 TEU). The dominant approach in most policy documents is to define the rule of law in terms of legal and institutional checklists. However, several authors have criticized this “anatomical” approach and have argued for a “sociological” approach. In this paper, I will discuss two empirical models of the rule of law. Most current studies follow the model of the “Rule of Law in Action.” This approach is based on Roscoe Pound’s distinction between the “law in the books” and the “law in action.” I will argue that this conventional approach has several shortcomings. I will therefore introduce an alternative model, based on Eugen Ehrlich’s concept of the “living law.” The principal concern of the “Living Rule of Law” model is not the level of social support but rather the social definition of the rule of law. To assess the strengths and weaknesses of both approaches, I will apply both models in a case study about rule of law reform in a refugee camp on the Thailand–Burma border. It will be concluded that empirical research is essential to evaluate the EU’s external action. Moreover, empirical studies based on the model of the Living Rule of Law support a legal pluralist approach, which focuses on the user perspective of citizens and which recognizes the contested notion of the rule of law across cultural borders.

Journal

Asia Europe Journal – Springer Journals

Published: Sep 24, 2015

References

  • Indices and indicators of justice, governance, and the rule of law: an overview
    Botero, JC; Nelson, RL; Pratt, C
  • From village to camp: refugee camp life in transition on the Thailand-Burma border
    Bowles, E
  • The new imperialism: violence, norms and the “rule of law”
    Brooks, RE
  • Analysis on the situation of the refugee camps from the rule of law aspect
  • The rule of law revival
    Carothers, T
  • Promoting the rule of law abroad: in search of knowledge
    Carothers, T
  • The sociology of law: an introduction
    Cotterrell, R
  • The administration of justice in refugee camps: a study of practice (UNHCR Legal and Protection Policy Research Series)
    Costa, R
  • The fundamental principles of the sociology of law
    Ehrlich, E
  • Comprehensive legal and judicial development
    Faundez, J
  • The new civil rights research: a constitutive approach
    Fleury-Steiner, B; Nielsen, LB
  • The morality of law
    Fuller, L
  • The importance of ideals: debating their relevance in law, morality, and politics
    Hertogh, M
  • A “European” conception of legal consciousness: rediscovering Eugen Ehrlich
    Hertogh, M
  • Living law: reconsidering Eugen Ehrlich
  • A sociology of the rule of law: why, what, where? And who cares?
    Hertogh, M
  • What happens to law in a refugee camp?
    Holzer, E
  • International relations and the problem of difference
    Inayatullah, N; Blanley, DL
  • A turn to legal pluralism in rule of law promotion?
    Janse, R
  • The cultural study of law: reconstructing legal scholarship
    Kahn, PW
  • Getting to the rule of law
    Krygier, M
  • Normative power Europe: a contradiction in terms?
    Manners, I
  • Governing refugees: justice, order and legal pluralism
    McConnachie, K
  • Rule of law dynamics: in an era of international and transnational governance
    Merkel, W
  • Legal pluralism
    Merry, SE
  • Measuring the world: indicators, human rights, and global governance
    Merry, SE
  • Law in action or living law? Back to the beginning in sociology of law
    Nelken, D
  • Let one hundred flowers bloom, one hundred schools contend: debating rule of law in China
    Peerenboom, R
  • Rule of law dynamics: in an era of international and transnational governance
    Peerenboom, R; Zürn, M; Nollkaemper, A
  • Adapting to changing legal frameworks: Mozambican refugees in South Africa
    Polzer, T
  • Law in books and law in action
    Pound, R
  • Innovations in rule of law: a compilation of concise essays
    Röder, TJ
  • On the rule of law: history, politics, theory
    Tamanaha, B
  • The rule of law and legal pluralism in development
    Tamanaha, B
  • Customary justice: perspectives on legal empowerment
  • Bringing justice to the poor, bottom-up legal development cooperation
    Rooij, B
  • Is the rule of law an essentially contested concept (in Florida)?
    Waldron, J
  • The concept and rule of law
    Waldron, J
  • The sociology behind Eugen Ehrlich’s sociology of law
    Ziegert, KA
  • Rule of law dynamics: in an era of international and transnational governance
    Zürn, M; Nollkaemper, A; Peerenboom, R