Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Factionalism as Argumentation: A Case Study of the Indigenous Communication Practices of Jemez Pueblo

Factionalism as Argumentation: A Case Study of the Indigenous Communication Practices of Jemez... This study identifies seven characteristics of argumentation and demonstrates how the factionalism of Jemez Pueblo in New Mexico serves as an indigenous form of argumentation for that society. We analyze two examples of factionalism: the case of the governor's authority and the case for religious freedom. In both, six phases of factionalism are identified and found to illustrate how this form of argumentation provides a useful method of decision-making for the Jemez. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Argumentation and Advocacy Taylor & Francis

Factionalism as Argumentation: A Case Study of the Indigenous Communication Practices of Jemez Pueblo

Littlefield, Robert S.; Ball, Jane A.
Argumentation and Advocacy , Volume 41 (2): 15 – Sep 1, 2004
Download PDF

Factionalism as Argumentation: A Case Study of the Indigenous Communication Practices of Jemez Pueblo

Abstract

This study identifies seven characteristics of argumentation and demonstrates how the factionalism of Jemez Pueblo in New Mexico serves as an indigenous form of argumentation for that society. We analyze two examples of factionalism: the case of the governor's authority and the case for religious freedom. In both, six phases of factionalism are identified and found to illustrate how this form of argumentation provides a useful method of decision-making for the Jemez.
Loading next page...
 
/lp/taylor-francis/factionalism-as-argumentation-a-case-study-of-the-indigenous-nN9yH8jL0r
Publisher
Taylor & Francis
Copyright
© 2004 Taylor and Francis Group, LLC
ISSN
2576-8476
eISSN
1051-1431
DOI
10.1080/00028533.2004.11821621
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

This study identifies seven characteristics of argumentation and demonstrates how the factionalism of Jemez Pueblo in New Mexico serves as an indigenous form of argumentation for that society. We analyze two examples of factionalism: the case of the governor's authority and the case for religious freedom. In both, six phases of factionalism are identified and found to illustrate how this form of argumentation provides a useful method of decision-making for the Jemez.

Journal

Argumentation and Advocacy – Taylor & Francis

Published: Sep 1, 2004

Keywords: factionalism; Jemez Pueblo; Greco-Roman; argumentation; mediation

References

  • How to do things with doxa: Toward an analysis of argumentation in discourse [Electronic version]
  • Where there are no rules or systems to guide us: Argument from example in a hermeneutic rhetoric
  • “Honey, I blew up the rhetorical tradition!”
  • Alliance or schism: The complexity of Pueblo culture
  • Faith and factionalism among the Senecas: Theory and ethnohistory [Electronic version]
  • The oldest typology of argumentation schemes [Electronic version]
  • Debate and dissent in late Tokugawa and Meiji Japan
  • Where is argument?
  • Pueblo factionalism and external relations
  • Toward reviving rationality in argument: Adding pieces to Johnson's Puzzle [Electronic version]
  • Design and the new rhetoric: Productive arts in the philosophy of culture [Electronic version]
  • Ethnogeography and the Native American past [Electronic version]
  • The Greek roots of the ad-hominem argument [Electronic version]
  • Knowledge-as-status: On argument and epistemology [Electronic version]
  • Isleta Pueblo
  • Within the iron horse: The struggle for Native American religious freedom in American prisons
  • Cycles of history in plateau sociopolitical organization: Reflections on the nature of indigenous band societies [Electronic version]
  • Classical Chinese conceptions of argumentation and persuasion
  • The “Three Doctrines Discussions” of Tang China: Religious debate as a rhetorical strategy [Electronic version]
  • Effing the ineffable: The logocentric fallacy in argumentation [Electronic version]
  • Wisdom of the people: Potential and pitfalls in efforts by the Comanches to recreate traditional ways of building consensus [Electronic version]
  • Reflections on rhetoric, deliberative democracy, civil society, and trust [Electronic version]
  • The promise(s) of deliberative democracy [Electronic version)
  • Values and practices in Asian argumentation
  • Authority-based argumentative strategies: A model for their evaluation [Electronic version]
  • Charles Henry Burke (1921–1929)
  • Students, leaders learn conflict-resolution technique
  • Zuni kin and clan
  • The Keresan component of southwestern Pueblo culture
  • Reinventing Native Americans in Fourth of July orations [Electronic version]
  • Rhetorical sovereignty: What do American Indians want from writing?
  • Argumentation communities
  • Tribal council elections in a southwestern Pueblo
  • Images of power in a southwestern Pueblo
  • The dance of healing: Psychiatrist Carl Hammerschlag offers healing lessons based on native American traditions [Electronic version]
  • Peacemaking as ceremony: The mediation model of the Navajo nation [Electronic version]
  • Indigenous knowledge and technology: Creating environmental justice in the 21st century [Electronic version]
  • Talking circles: A native American approach to experiential learning [Electronic version]
  • Returning to the circle: The long journey of American Indian tribes to a renewal of sovereignty [Electronic version]
  • Intertribal dance and cross cultural communication: Traditional powwows in Ohio
  • Rhêtorikê: What's in a name? Toward a revised history of early Greek rhetorical theory [Electronic version]
  • Pecos Pueblo
  • Corporate advocacy as argumentation
  • Social disorganization in Picuris Pueblo
  • Pervasive factionalism
  • The cultural and social survival of a Pueblo Indian community
  • Oratory, democracy, and the culture of participation [Electronic version]
  • Introduction to case study
  • Application of a case study methodology
  • Ancient Greek origins of argumentation theory: Plato's transformation of dialegesthai to dialectic
  • Old Oraibi: A study of the Hopi Indians of the third mesa
  • The New Rhetoric's argument schemes: A rhetorical view of practical reasoning
  • Deliberative democracy and the rhetorical production of political culture [Electronic version]
  • Three perspectives on argument: Rhetoric, dialectic, and logic
  • Miscellaneous notes on the Keresan Pueblos
  • Governance within the Navajo nation [Electronic version]
  • Civil society in China: A dynamic field of study [Electronic version]
  • Future directions in argumentation theory and practice