Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Obnoxious Plants and Pestiferous Growths: how figurative language reinforces the management of weeds in Victoria, Australia

Obnoxious Plants and Pestiferous Growths: how figurative language reinforces the management of... The militaristic metaphors common in public discourses about invasive species have been criticised for promoting combative management approaches and constraining policy responses. But are they really to blame for entrenching a command-and-control approach to managing weeds in Australia? Since 2000, almost every state and territory has introduced new biosecurity legislation encouraging ‘shared responsibility’. Yet, this term remains noticeably absent from new legislation in Victoria. We aim to examine whether public discourses around invasive plants have remained unchanged to better understand how invasive plants have been framed and whether this can provide insight into the lack of engagement with ‘shared responsibility’ in Victorian legislation. This study investigates figurative language used in Victorian newspapers from 1885 to 2020 to describe three invasive plants and their management: Bathurst burr, blackberry and gorse. The figurative language reveals limited acknowledgement of humans' role in the spread of weeds and emphasis on the diverse impacts of weeds on humans. Militaristic metaphors have existed for over 130 years, but are neither the most predominant nor community-mobilising. Overall, figurative language has focused on individual efforts to control weeds, without critical analysis of the inter-relationships between humans and weeds nor having created opportunities for caring or collaborative weed management. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Australian Geographer Taylor & Francis

Obnoxious Plants and Pestiferous Growths: how figurative language reinforces the management of weeds in Victoria, Australia

Download PDF
18 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/taylor-francis/obnoxious-plants-and-pestiferous-growths-how-figurative-language-qVIfQtQvS0

References

References for this paper are not available at this time. We will be adding them shortly, thank you for your patience.

Publisher
Taylor & Francis
Copyright
© 2022 Geographical Society of New South Wales Inc.
ISSN
1465-3311
eISSN
0004-9182
DOI
10.1080/00049182.2022.2116969
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

The militaristic metaphors common in public discourses about invasive species have been criticised for promoting combative management approaches and constraining policy responses. But are they really to blame for entrenching a command-and-control approach to managing weeds in Australia? Since 2000, almost every state and territory has introduced new biosecurity legislation encouraging ‘shared responsibility’. Yet, this term remains noticeably absent from new legislation in Victoria. We aim to examine whether public discourses around invasive plants have remained unchanged to better understand how invasive plants have been framed and whether this can provide insight into the lack of engagement with ‘shared responsibility’ in Victorian legislation. This study investigates figurative language used in Victorian newspapers from 1885 to 2020 to describe three invasive plants and their management: Bathurst burr, blackberry and gorse. The figurative language reveals limited acknowledgement of humans' role in the spread of weeds and emphasis on the diverse impacts of weeds on humans. Militaristic metaphors have existed for over 130 years, but are neither the most predominant nor community-mobilising. Overall, figurative language has focused on individual efforts to control weeds, without critical analysis of the inter-relationships between humans and weeds nor having created opportunities for caring or collaborative weed management.

Journal

Australian Geographer – Taylor & Francis

Published: Apr 3, 2023

Keywords: Area-wide management; invasion biology; media analysis; rhetoric; natural resource management; pest plants; human-plant relations

References

  • Exploring Natural Resource Management with Metaphor Analysis
  • Ecology and Control of Blackberry (Rubus Fruticosus L. agg.) I. Rubus spp. as Weeds in Victoria
  • Eradicating Bodies in Invasive Plant Management
  • Emergence and Flowering in Xanthium Spinosum
  • From Killing Lists to Healthy Country: Aboriginal Approaches to Weed Control in the Kimberley, Western Australia
  • Speaking About Weeds: Indigenous Elders’ Metaphors for Invasive Species and Their Management
  • Vernacular Knowledge and Environmental Law: Cause and Cure for Regulatory Failure
  • Using Thematic Analysis in Psychology
  • Communicating with the Public About Emerald ash Borer: Militaristic and Fatalistic Framings in the News Media
  • Brexit and Invasive Species: A Case Study of the Cognitive and Affective Encoding of ‘Abject Nature’ in Contemporary Nationalist Ideology
  • Site-versus Species-Based Approaches to Weed Management in Australia
  • Friends or foe? Invasive Species and Public Green Space in Toronto
  • Amenity Migrants, Animals and Ambivalent Natures: More-Than-Human Encounters at Home in the Rural Residential Estate
  • Sticky Lives: Slugs, Detachment and More-Than-Human Ethics in the Garden
  • Three Cooperative Pathways to Solving a Collective Weed Management Problem
  • A New Perspective on the Trust Power Nexus from Rural Australia
  • How Local Landholder Groups Collectively Manage Weeds in South-Eastern Australia
  • Communicating About Invasive Species: How “Driver” and “Passenger” Models Influence Public Willingness to Take Action
  • The Social Dimensions of Invasive Plants
  • Governing Invasive Plants: Policy and Practice in Managing the Gamba Grass (Andropogon Gayanus) – Bushfire Nexus in Northern Australia
  • The Distinctive Capacities of Plants: Re-Thinking Difference via Invasive Species
  • Nativeness, Invasiveness, and Nation in Australian Plants
  • The Role of Social Norms in Collective Action for Weed Management Across Rural Private Property
  • Living with Plants and the Exploration of Botanical Encounter Within Human Geographic Research Practice
  • Does Invasive Species Research use More Militaristic Language Than Other Ecology and Conservation Biology Literature?
  • Led up the Garden Path? Weeds, Conservation Rhetoric, and Environmental Management
  • Emerging Amenity Landscapes: Invasive Weeds and Land Subdivision in Rural Australia
  • Acacia Exchanges: Wattles, Thorn Trees, and the Study of Plant Movements
  • Metaphors and Biorisks: The War on Infectious Diseases and Invasive Species
  • Managing Invasive Plants in a Rural-Amenity Landscape: The Role of Social Capital and Landcare
  • Metaphor and Politics
  • Surfing the Money Tides: Understanding the Foreign Exchange Market Through Metaphors
  • Why Metaphors are Necessary and not Just Nice
  • Telling the Farmers’ Story: Competing Responses to Soil Conservation Rhetoric
  • The Social and Cultural Construction of Farming Practice: ‘Good’ Farming in Two New South Wales Communities
  • Pests and Home-Making: Depictions of Pests in Homemaker Magazines
  • Border-processes and Homemaking: Encounters with Possums in Suburban Australian Homes
  • Comparing Invasive Networks: Cultural and Political Biographies of Invasive Species
  • Explaining People’s Perceptions of Invasive Alien Species: A Conceptual Framework
  • Pour une autre représentation métaphorique des invasions biologiques
  • Indigeneity, Ferality, and What ‘Belongs’ in the Australian Bush: Aboriginal Responses to ‘Introduced’ Animals and Plants in a Settler-Descendant Society