Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Power, institutions and rents in two South African cities

Power, institutions and rents in two South African cities Through case studies of two South African metropolitan municipalities, Cape Town and Nelson Mandela Bay, the paper explores the way in which the economic advantages at the disposal of local government, referred to as rents, are distributed according to the power relations in cities. The city governance regimes are distinguished in the way that power is structured, the balance between formal and informal institutions, the nature of the rents allocated, and their developmental and spatial outcomes. Cape Town’s growth-oriented model, founded on intimate relationships between developers and the political elite, exercised centralized control over land rights, which were allocated to entrenched property interests. The weaker clientelist regime in Nelson Mandela Bay relied on a diminishing pool of procurement rents to sustain a decentralized patronage-based system. The paper uses a political settlements framework to understand how the configuration of power in each city is sustained by a particular distribution of rents, mobilized through informal institutions, which in turn impact the structuring of the bureaucracy. The spatial and developmental impacts of the case studies indicate that despite the better development outcomes of Cape Town, neither regime specifically advantages the urban poor. The paper concludes by suggesting ways in which political settlements theory can better account for bureaucratic autonomy and impacts on the space economy. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Area Development and Policy Taylor & Francis

Power, institutions and rents in two South African cities

Olver, Crispian
Area Development and Policy , Volume 6 (3): 21 – Jul 3, 2021
Download PDF

Power, institutions and rents in two South African cities

Abstract

Through case studies of two South African metropolitan municipalities, Cape Town and Nelson Mandela Bay, the paper explores the way in which the economic advantages at the disposal of local government, referred to as rents, are distributed according to the power relations in cities. The city governance regimes are distinguished in the way that power is structured, the balance between formal and informal institutions, the nature of the rents allocated, and their developmental and spatial...
Loading next page...
 
/lp/taylor-francis/power-institutions-and-rents-in-two-south-african-cities-kFCm0oyUWe
Publisher
Taylor & Francis
Copyright
© 2020 Regional Studies Association
ISSN
2379-2957
eISSN
2379-2949
DOI
10.1080/23792949.2020.1793680
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Through case studies of two South African metropolitan municipalities, Cape Town and Nelson Mandela Bay, the paper explores the way in which the economic advantages at the disposal of local government, referred to as rents, are distributed according to the power relations in cities. The city governance regimes are distinguished in the way that power is structured, the balance between formal and informal institutions, the nature of the rents allocated, and their developmental and spatial outcomes. Cape Town’s growth-oriented model, founded on intimate relationships between developers and the political elite, exercised centralized control over land rights, which were allocated to entrenched property interests. The weaker clientelist regime in Nelson Mandela Bay relied on a diminishing pool of procurement rents to sustain a decentralized patronage-based system. The paper uses a political settlements framework to understand how the configuration of power in each city is sustained by a particular distribution of rents, mobilized through informal institutions, which in turn impact the structuring of the bureaucracy. The spatial and developmental impacts of the case studies indicate that despite the better development outcomes of Cape Town, neither regime specifically advantages the urban poor. The paper concludes by suggesting ways in which political settlements theory can better account for bureaucratic autonomy and impacts on the space economy.

Journal

Area Development and Policy – Taylor & Francis

Published: Jul 3, 2021

Keywords: local government; urban governance; political settlements; informal institutions; holding power; clientelism; rents; rent-seeking; spatial planning; space-economy; P48; R58; 当地政府; 城市治理; 政治解决; 非正规机构; 持有权; 修正主义; 租金; 寻租; 空间规划; 空间经济; administraciones locales; gobernanza urbana; acuerdos políticos; instituciones informales; capacidad de retención; clientelismo; rentas; búsqueda de rentas; planificación espacial; economía espacial; Местное самоуправление; городское управление; политический компромисс; неформальные институты; блокирующая власть; клиентелизм; рента; поиск ренты; пространственное планирование; пространственная экономика

References

  • State capacity and economic development: A network approach
  • Consolidated general report on the local government outcomes: MFMA 2016/17
  • MFMA 2017/18 consolidated general report on the local government audit outcomes
  • A city asset or potential development node?
  • Studying political settlements in Africa
  • Power, patronage, and gatekeeper politics in South Africa
  • Everyday corruption and the state: Citizens and public officials in Africa
  • Cape Town planning officials slam property development, but politicians disagree
  • Five year integrated development plan July 2017 – June 2022
  • Citizen satisfaction index shows sharp decline in citizen trust across SA’s largest metropolitan municipalities
  • Integrated urban development framework implementation plan 2016–2019
  • Assignment inception report for project RFQ 13102015 VA49/516
  • Wescape: Why build a New City for 800, 000 people more than 40km away from Cape Town? | FUTURE CAPE TOWN | OUR FUTURE CITIES
  • Seeing political settlements through the city: A framework for comparative analysis of urban transformation
  • Address by Brett Herron to Cape Town Press Club
  • Legal corruption
  • Affidavit under the provisions of the protected disclosures Act No 26 of 2000 (‘PDA’)
  • The efficiency implications of corruption
  • Political settlements and the governance of growth-enhancing institutions
  • Political settlements and the analysis of institutions
  • Did Cape Town lose millions on foreshore land sale?
  • GroundUp: City of Cape Town fails to explain R140m property sale bungle
  • Economic development through bureaucratic corruption
  • De Lille and the contentious Clifton Scenic Reserve megaproject
  • Public opinion: Performance of local government report
  • Corruption and political development: A cost–benefit analysis
  • Provincial–regional ANC politics in the Northern Cape: Corruption or everyday informal practices?
  • Patronage and politics in a South African city: A case study of Nelson Mandela Bay
  • 25 Year review of South African local government
  • The ‘Right to the city’: Institutional imperatives of a developmental state
  • The seeds of perpetual instability: The case of Mogalakwena local municipality in South Africa
  • Report to planning and environment portfolio committee
  • The ‘Perverse effects’ of political corruption
  • 2016/17 State of transformation report for the South African property sector
  • Constitution of the Republic of South Africa
  • An economic view of corruption
  • Community survey 2016
  • The state of basic service delivery in South Africa: In-depth analysis of the community survey 2016 data
  • Selected building statistics of the private sector as reported by local government institutions (Preliminary)
  • Urban regimes and the capacity to govern: A political economy approach
  • Reflections on regime politics: From governing coalition to urban political order
  • Clientelism, corruption & catastrophe
  • Cape of storms to come: Part 2
  • Report: Investigation into allegations involving the executive Mayor Alderman Patricia De Lille
  • The political economy of corruption: Elite-formation, factions and violence
  • Insurgent citizenship, collective violence and the struggle for a place in the New South Africa
  • A reconsideration of the theory of rent
  • Doing business in South Africa 2018