Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Semantic role assignment in Danish children and adults

Semantic role assignment in Danish children and adults In resolving “who did what to whom” in an active transitive clause, language users rely on intrasentential cues like word order, animacy and case marking. Most frequently, these cues will all point towards the same interpretation. For instance, in He kicked the ball, the agent he is both cued by word order (preverbal), animacy and case (the nominative). However, in Danish where word order may be subject to pragmatically motivated variations and thus allow for both subject-before-object and object-before-subject structures, conflicts often occur between the word order cue and other formal cues. Previous experiments in a variety of languages have shown that sentences with conflicting formal cues are habitually miscomprehended by pre-school children. For adults, they continue to be more difficult to read and comprehend, often being shallowly processed on the basis of heuristics. However, most previous experiments have presented sentences in isolation, that is, in situations that render a context-demanding structure with conflicting formal cues decidedly inappropriate. In this study we therefore cross the sentence boundary to investigate the interplay between intra- and extrasentential cues in Danish sentence comprehension. Comparing corpus data with recent act-out and reading experiments involving Danish sentences with conflicting formal cues, we argue that context plays an important role in the resolution of semantic role distribution. Children and adults weigh morphosyntactic cues differently, but we find a striking continuity in attention to context across development: when interpreting conflict clauses with object-before-subject structure, both children and adults systematically integrate intra- and extrasentential cues to assign semantic roles. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Acta Linguistica Hafniensia: International Taylor & Francis

Semantic role assignment in Danish children and adults

Download PDF
40 pages

Semantic role assignment in Danish children and adults

Abstract

In resolving “who did what to whom” in an active transitive clause, language users rely on intrasentential cues like word order, animacy and case marking. Most frequently, these cues will all point towards the same interpretation. For instance, in He kicked the ball, the agent he is both cued by word order (preverbal), animacy and case (the nominative). However, in Danish where word order may be subject to pragmatically motivated variations and thus allow for both...
Loading next page...
 
/lp/taylor-francis/semantic-role-assignment-in-danish-children-and-adults-XJ1AFbeYbR
Publisher
Taylor & Francis
Copyright
© 2014 The Linguistic Circle of Copenhagen
ISSN
1949-0763
eISSN
0374-0463
DOI
10.1080/03740463.2014.990291
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

In resolving “who did what to whom” in an active transitive clause, language users rely on intrasentential cues like word order, animacy and case marking. Most frequently, these cues will all point towards the same interpretation. For instance, in He kicked the ball, the agent he is both cued by word order (preverbal), animacy and case (the nominative). However, in Danish where word order may be subject to pragmatically motivated variations and thus allow for both subject-before-object and object-before-subject structures, conflicts often occur between the word order cue and other formal cues. Previous experiments in a variety of languages have shown that sentences with conflicting formal cues are habitually miscomprehended by pre-school children. For adults, they continue to be more difficult to read and comprehend, often being shallowly processed on the basis of heuristics. However, most previous experiments have presented sentences in isolation, that is, in situations that render a context-demanding structure with conflicting formal cues decidedly inappropriate. In this study we therefore cross the sentence boundary to investigate the interplay between intra- and extrasentential cues in Danish sentence comprehension. Comparing corpus data with recent act-out and reading experiments involving Danish sentences with conflicting formal cues, we argue that context plays an important role in the resolution of semantic role distribution. Children and adults weigh morphosyntactic cues differently, but we find a striking continuity in attention to context across development: when interpreting conflict clauses with object-before-subject structure, both children and adults systematically integrate intra- and extrasentential cues to assign semantic roles.

Journal

Acta Linguistica Hafniensia: International – Taylor & Francis

Published: Jul 3, 2014

Keywords: sentence processing; L1 acquisition; word order; case; context; cue conflicts

References

  • Interaction with Context during Human Sentence Processing
  • Subject-Object Ambiguities in German Embedded Clauses: An Across-the-Board Comparison
  • The Odense Language Acquisition Project
  • Competition, Variation and Language Learning
  • Functionalism and the Competition Model
  • Between Emergence and Mastery: The Long Developmental Route of Language Acquisition
  • OVS i dansk [OVS in Danish]
  • Danske børnehavebørns forståelse og produktion af sætninger med OVS-struktur [Danish Kindergarteners’ Comprehension and Production of Sentences with OVS Structure]
  • Contrastive Accent and Contrastive Stress
  • The Role of Contrast in the Local Licensing of Scrambling in German: Evidence from Online Comprehension
  • Givenness, Contrastiveness, Definiteness, Subjects, Topics and Point of View
  • Neustik, tropik og frastik: Ytringens kommunikative aspekter
  • German Children's Comprehension of Word Order and Case Marking in Causative Sentences
  • On the Architecture of Topic and Focus
  • Sound Patterns of Syntax: Object Shift
  • The Misinterpretation of Noncanonical Sentences
  • Cognitive Status and Form of Referring Expressions in Discourse
  • Interaction between Particles and Word Order in the Comprehension and Production of Simple Sentences in Japanese Children
  • Semantic Content and Linguistic Structure in Functional Grammar. On the Semantics of ‘Nounhood’
  • Editing for Speaking: First Position, Foregrounding and Object Fronting in Danish and English
  • Developing the Ability to Resolve Syntactic Ambiguity
  • One Frog, Two Frog, Red Frog, Blue Frog: Factors Affecting Children's Syntactic Choices in Production and Comprehension
  • Effect of Word Order and Case Marking on Sentence Processing in Finnish: An Eye Fixation Analysis
  • Effects of NP Type on the Resolution of Word-Order Ambiguities
  • Processing of Morphological and Semantic Cues in Russian and German
  • Lexical and Referential Cues to Sentence Interpretation: An Investigation of Children's Interpretations of Ambiguous Sentences
  • Basic Notions of Information Structure
  • Context, You Need. Experimental Approaches to Information Structure Processing
  • Context Improves Comprehension of Fronted Objects
  • Context Predicts Word Order Processing in Broca's Region
  • Information Structure and Sentence Form
  • Cue Validity and Sentence Interpretation in English, German, and Italian
  • The Acquisition of Cue-Category Mappings
  • VP Anaphora and Verb-Second Order in Danish
  • On Different Kinds of Contrast
  • Discourse Configurationality in Finnish and Hungarian
  • R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria
  • Children Use Canonical Sentence Schemas: A Crosslinguistic Study of Word Order and Inflections
  • Danish
  • Referential and Syntactic Processes: What Develops?
  • The Kindergarten-Path Effect: Studying On-line Sentence Processing in Young Children
  • The Informational Component
  • On Rheme and Kontrast
  • Establishing Reference in Language Comprehension: An Electrophysiological Perspective
  • Contextual Licensing of Marked OVS Word Order in German
  • Contrastive Focus