Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Intermediaries, isomorphic activism and programming for social accountability in Pakistan

Intermediaries, isomorphic activism and programming for social accountability in Pakistan Using ethnographic research from Pakistan, this paper argues that social accountability programmes that overlook the role of intermediaries in clientelistic states risk undermining the wider democratising projects they seek to support. It proposes a theory of ‘isomorphic activism’ that describes how these public authorities appropriate others' opportunities to participate in politics and, in the process, undermine democratic norms. Isomorphic activism is shown to be more likely when programmes are based on ideals of civil society that render activism a technical exercise, depoliticise it and blind donors to power inequalities. The challenges the paper highlights are important given calls for development programmes to change by whom and how politics is done, whilst granting local ownership to participants and demonstrating value for money. They should also be of interest to those concerned by the spread of reductive views of civil society activism within donor organisations. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Global Policy Wiley

Intermediaries, isomorphic activism and programming for social accountability in Pakistan

Kirk, Tom
Global Policy , Volume Early View – May 23, 2023
Download PDF
11 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/wiley/intermediaries-isomorphic-activism-and-programming-for-social-27BqTVJuCH
Publisher
Wiley
Copyright
Copyright © 2023 University of Durham and John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
ISSN
1758-5880
eISSN
1758-5899
DOI
10.1111/1758-5899.13218
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Using ethnographic research from Pakistan, this paper argues that social accountability programmes that overlook the role of intermediaries in clientelistic states risk undermining the wider democratising projects they seek to support. It proposes a theory of ‘isomorphic activism’ that describes how these public authorities appropriate others' opportunities to participate in politics and, in the process, undermine democratic norms. Isomorphic activism is shown to be more likely when programmes are based on ideals of civil society that render activism a technical exercise, depoliticise it and blind donors to power inequalities. The challenges the paper highlights are important given calls for development programmes to change by whom and how politics is done, whilst granting local ownership to participants and demonstrating value for money. They should also be of interest to those concerned by the spread of reductive views of civil society activism within donor organisations.

Journal

Global Policy – Wiley

Published: May 23, 2023

References

  • The state as landlord in Pakistani Punjab: peasant struggles on the Okara military farms
    Akhtar, A.S.
  • The limits of institutional reform in development
    Andrews, M.
  • Bootstrapping democracy: transforming local governance and civil society in Brazil
    Baiocchi, G.; Heller, P.; Silva, M.K.
  • Patronage as politics in South Asia
    Berenschot, W.
  • Local development brokers in Africa: the rise of a new social category
    Bierschenk, T.; Chauveau, J.P.; Olivier de Sardan, J.P.
  • Constructing grounded theory: a practical guide through qualitative analysis
    Charmaz, K.
  • The politics of the governed: reflections on popular politics in Most of the world
    Chatterjee, P.
  • Spaces for change? The politics of participation in new democratic arenas
    Cornwall, A.; Coelho, V.S.
  • Progressive patronage? Municipalities, NGOs, CBOs and the limits to slum dwellers' Empowerment
    Wit, J.; Berner, W.
  • Supporting transparency, accountability and electoral process in Pakistan (first annual review)
  • Supporting transparency, accountability and electoral process in Pakistan (second annual review)
  • Supporting transparency, accountability and electoral process in Pakistan (third annual review)
  • Supporting transparency, accountability and electoral processes in Pakistan: Programme (completion report)
  • The anti‐politics machine: ‘development’, Depoliticization and bureaucratic power in Lesotho
    Ferguson, J.
  • Deepening democracy
    Fung, A.; Wright, E.
  • Ethnographies of aid: exploring development texts and encounters
    Gould, J.
  • Justice and security research Programme, paper 7
    Hoffmann, K.; Kirk, T.
  • The Oxford handbook of governance and limited statehood
    Hönke, J.; Müller, M.M.
  • Conceptualizing political Clientelism: political exchange and democratic theory Jonathan
    Hopkin, J.
  • Class, power, and patronage: the landed elite and politics in Pakistani Punjab
    Javid, H.
  • Power, politics and programming for social accountability in Pakistan
    Kirk, T.
  • Routledge handbook of public policy in Africa
    Kirk, T.; Allen, T.
  • Aramis, or the love of technology
    Latour, B.
  • Varieties of activist experience: civil Society in South Asia
    Lewis, D.
  • Organising and representing the poor in a Clientelistic democracy: the decline of radical INGOs in Bangladesh
    Lewis, D.
  • The will to improve: governmentality, development, and the practice of politics
    Li, T.
  • IDS working paper 550
    Loureiro, M.; Pracha, M.; Ahmed, A.; Khan, D.; Ali, M.
  • Anthropology & Development
    Mair, L.
  • Small‐time political fixers in India's states: "towel over armpit"
    Manor, J.
  • Community‐based and – driven development: a critical review
    Mansuri, G.; Rao, V.
  • Postdevelopment, professionalism, and the politics of participation
    Mckinnon, K.
  • Cultivating development: an ethnography of aid policy and practice
    Mosse, D.
  • Public services at the crossroads – ten years after the world development report 2004: reflections on the past decade and implications for the future
  • Patronage as politics in South Asia
    Piliavsky, A.
  • Development in practice: paved with good intentions
    Porter, D.; Allen, B.; Thompson, G.
  • The Pyraveekar: "the fixer" in rural India
    Reddy, G.; Haragopa, G.
  • Democracy
    Tilly, C.
  • Making services work for poor people
  • Beyond the technocrat? The professional expert in development practice
    Wilson, G.